School for Environment and Sustainability, University of Michigan, 440 Church Street, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48104, United States.
US Army Corps of Engineers, 477 Michigan Avenue, Detroit, Michigan 48226, United States.
Environ Sci Technol. 2022 Aug 2;56(15):11061-11070. doi: 10.1021/acs.est.2c02820. Epub 2022 Jul 21.
Capturing precipitation-based episodes is a longstanding issue for estimating tributary loads; however, wind-driven resuspension in Lake Huron creates similar uncertainties in its estimated load to Lake Erie. Recent suggestions that the phosphorus load from Lake Huron is underestimated because sampling frequencies miss contributions from resuspension events are speculative because they did not include direct load measurements, address all resuspension regions, or assess the potential bioavailability of the load. We address these shortcomings by evaluating Lake Huron's nearshore regions, characterizing the biological availability of the load, and providing direct comparisons of load estimates with and without the resuspended load. We show that total phosphorus concentrations in Lake Huron and the St. Clair River are higher during resuspension events and that bioavailability of that material is comparable to that reported elsewhere. New load estimates, based on continuous turbidity measurements converted to phosphorus through P-turbidity relationships, were almost 90% higher than traditional load estimates, providing empirical evidence for the significantly underestimated previous load. This confirmation is important because if the Lake Huron load is not decreased, reductions from other sources would be needed to meet the overall reduction targets set by the binational Great Lakes Water Quality Agreement.
捕捉基于降水的事件是估算支流负荷的一个长期存在的问题;然而,休伦湖的风驱动再悬浮在估算其向伊利湖的负荷时也会产生类似的不确定性。最近有人提出,由于采样频率错过了再悬浮事件的贡献,休伦湖的磷负荷被低估了,这种说法是推测性的,因为它们没有包括直接负荷测量、解决所有再悬浮区域,或评估负荷的潜在生物利用度。我们通过评估休伦湖的近岸区域、描述负荷的生物可利用性,并提供有无再悬浮负荷的负荷估计的直接比较,来解决这些缺点。我们表明,休伦湖和圣克莱尔河的总磷浓度在再悬浮事件期间更高,并且该物质的生物利用度与其他地方报道的相似。基于通过 P-浊度关系将连续浊度测量值转换为磷的新负荷估计值几乎比传统负荷估计值高 90%,为以前负荷明显被低估提供了经验证据。这种确认很重要,因为如果不降低休伦湖的负荷,就需要从其他来源减少负荷,以达到由美加两国《大湖水质协定》设定的总体减排目标。