Department of Sociology, California State University, Hayward, CA, United States of America.
Osher Center for Integrative Medicine, University of California San Francisco, San Francisco, CA, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2022 Jul 21;17(7):e0271691. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0271691. eCollection 2022.
Transgender and non-binary people face challenges in accessing gender affirming hormone therapy. Family planning clinics across the United States have greatly expanded transgender care services in the last ten years offering increased access to these services. This national qualitative study describes transgender and non-binary patients' experiences of receiving transgender care in family planning clinics. We completed 34 in-depth interviews with transgender and non-binary people over age 18 who had received transition-related care at a family planning clinic in the last year from 2019-2020. We analyzed interview data in Dedoose using constant comparative analysis and inductive thematic analysis. Patients reported overwhelmingly positive experiences at family planning clinics and were especially surprised at the ease and speed of the informed consent process. Barriers to care remain for patients in rural areas, low income patients, and patients who need specialized care. Some of the barriers relate to the gender binary and transphobia built into the medical systems, which cause patients and providers to have to find "work arounds" the binary medical and insurance systems. Patients also shared their idealized visions of transition related care that center on strong referral networks and hiring of LGBTQ staff at the clinics. Family planning clinics currently provide affirming and supportive care, especially those that use the informed consent model. Family planning clinics could provide increased access to transgender healthcare outside of major metropolitan areas and for transgender and gender non-conforming clients across the lifespan.
跨性别和非二元性别者在获得性别肯定激素治疗方面面临挑战。美国各地的计划生育诊所十年来大大扩大了跨性别护理服务,增加了获得这些服务的机会。这项全国性的定性研究描述了跨性别和非二元性别者在计划生育诊所接受跨性别护理的体验。我们对 2019 年至 2020 年间在计划生育诊所接受过与过渡相关护理的 18 岁以上跨性别和非二元性别者进行了 34 次深入访谈。我们使用 Dedoose 对访谈数据进行了恒比分析和归纳主题分析。患者报告说在计划生育诊所的体验非常积极,对知情同意过程的简单和快速感到特别惊讶。农村地区、低收入患者和需要特殊护理的患者仍然存在护理障碍。一些障碍与医疗系统中固有的性别二元论和跨性别恐惧症有关,这导致患者和提供者不得不寻找“解决办法”来绕过二元医疗和保险系统。患者还分享了他们理想的与过渡相关的护理愿景,这些愿景以强大的转诊网络和诊所雇用 LGBTQ 工作人员为中心。计划生育诊所目前提供肯定和支持性的护理,特别是那些使用知情同意模式的诊所。计划生育诊所可以在主要大都市区以外为跨性别和性别不符合者提供更多的跨性别医疗保健,并为整个生命周期的跨性别和性别不符合者提供服务。