Pharmacognosy and Phytotherapy, UCL School of Pharmacy, 29 - 39 Brunswick Sq, London, UK
Department of Applied Pharmaceutical Sciences and Clinical Pharmacy, Isra University, Amman, Jordan.
BMJ Open. 2022 Jul 27;12(7):e057405. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2021-057405.
Pharmacists are ideal partners for engaging with the needs and expectations of patients. They can play a vital role by providing information and supplying herbal medicines. In some community settings, pharmacists are also the main first point of care. This study explored Jordanian community pharmacists' perspectives and knowledge of herbal medicines available in pharmacies.
A cross-sectional study using an online survey was developed, and it was distributed via social media platforms. The one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) test was used to compare the mean knowledge scores between different demographic groups. Multiple linear regression analysis was used to identify predictors of herbal medicines knowledge.
Jordanian community pharmacies.
401 Jordanian community pharmacists.
Herbal supplements are sold in practically all pharmacies (98.5%). Slimming aids (14.7%), followed by sexual and sports enhancements (14%) and maintaining general health (12.1%) were most requested by Jordanian customers. While supplements for maintaining general health (12%), followed by slimming aids (11.4%) and skin conditions (9.3%) were most recommended by Jordanian pharmacists. 63.1% were not aware of potential herb-drug interactions, 95.6% did not receive complaints from customers about herbal medicines and 41.2% would not report adverse reactions to the national pharmacovigilance services. The mean knowledge score for knowledge of use, regulation, adverse reactions, and drug interactions was 3.7 (SD: 0.7), 3.5 (SD: 0.8), 3.6 (SD: 0.8), and 3.6 (SD: 0.8) (out of 5), respectively. ANOVA test showed that total pharmacists' knowledge scores significantly differed based on the length of time practising pharmacy (p<0.05).
This study highlights some key concerns relating to recommendations, awareness and reporting of herbal medicines among Jordanian community pharmacists. Pharmacists need enhanced education to provide objective and evidence-based information on the benefits-risks of herbal medicines. Future studies need to be carried out to confirm whether our findings are transferable to other Middle Eastern countries.
药剂师是满足患者需求和期望的理想合作伙伴。他们可以通过提供信息和供应草药来发挥重要作用。在一些社区环境中,药剂师也是主要的第一护理点。本研究探讨了约旦社区药剂师对药店供应的草药的看法和知识。
采用横断面研究,开发了在线调查,并通过社交媒体平台进行了分发。单因素方差分析(ANOVA)检验用于比较不同人口统计学群体之间的平均知识得分。多元线性回归分析用于确定草药知识的预测因素。
约旦社区药店。
401 名约旦社区药剂师。
几乎所有药店(98.5%)都出售草药补充剂。减肥药(14.7%),其次是性和运动增强剂(14%)和维持一般健康(12.1%)是约旦顾客最需要的。而维持一般健康的补充剂(12%),其次是减肥药(11.4%)和皮肤状况(9.3%)是约旦药剂师最推荐的。63.1%的药剂师不知道潜在的草药-药物相互作用,95.6%的药剂师没有收到顾客对草药的投诉,41.2%的药剂师不会向国家药物警戒服务报告不良反应。对使用、监管、不良反应和药物相互作用的知识的平均知识得分分别为 3.7(SD:0.7)、3.5(SD:0.8)、3.6(SD:0.8)和 3.6(SD:0.8)(满分 5 分)。方差分析检验表明,药剂师的总知识得分根据从事药学的时间长短而显著不同(p<0.05)。
本研究强调了约旦社区药剂师在草药推荐、意识和报告方面的一些关键问题。药剂师需要接受强化教育,以提供有关草药的益处-风险的客观和基于证据的信息。需要进行未来的研究,以确认我们的研究结果是否可推广到其他中东国家。