Rooney Nayahamui Michelle, Forsyth Miranda, Goa Joshua, Lawihin Dunstan, Kuir-Ayius Dora
School of Culture, History and Language, College of Asia and the Pacific, Australian National University, Canberra, Australia.
School of Regulation and Global Governance (RegNet), College of Asia and the Pacific, The Australian National University, Canberra, Australia.
Cult Health Sex. 2023 Jul;25(7):847-862. doi: 10.1080/13691058.2022.2103736. Epub 2022 Jul 29.
Papua New Guinea (PNG) has introduced laws and policies aimed at protecting women from intimate partner violence. This article examines how men who live in Lae, PNG, have made sense of and reacted to these laws and policies. Two evocative metaphors -'popcorn' and 'blanket' - emerge from our research. For 'popcorn', we see how the reforms created a chain reaction similar to that when popcorn is made. Using this metaphor, we analyse men's responses to the reforms, which range from a perceived threat to their cultural dominance, to fears about their personal problems being made public, to practical limits of the reforms. For 'blanket', we show how laws and policies can act like a blanket to smother men's agency in resolving violence and conflict within their homes and communities. The blanket metaphor further highlights how women's ability to seek support under the new laws are constrained by PNG's male dominated society. Adopting the idea that productive change is sometimes incremental, we argue that reforms focused on creating paradigmatic change through legislation and state policies should not occur at the expense of open-mindedness to partial and incomplete local innovations in reducing intimate partner violence.
巴布亚新几内亚(PNG)已出台旨在保护妇女免受亲密伴侣暴力侵害的法律和政策。本文探讨了生活在巴布亚新几内亚莱城的男性如何理解这些法律和政策并做出反应。我们的研究中出现了两个引人联想的隐喻——“爆米花”和“毯子”。对于“爆米花”,我们看到改革如何引发了类似于制作爆米花时的连锁反应。运用这个隐喻,我们分析了男性对改革的反应,这些反应包括从感觉到对其文化主导地位的威胁,到担心个人问题被公开,再到改革的实际局限性。对于“毯子”,我们展示了法律和政策如何像毯子一样抑制男性在解决家庭和社区内暴力与冲突方面的能动性。毯子这个隐喻进一步凸显了在巴布亚新几内亚男性主导的社会中,女性依据新法律寻求支持的能力受到了限制。秉持生产性变革有时是渐进式的这一观点,我们认为,旨在通过立法和国家政策实现范式变革的改革,不应以牺牲对减少亲密伴侣暴力方面局部和不完整的地方创新持开放态度为代价。