Vishnu Venugopalan Y, Bhatia Rohit, Khurana Dheeraj, Ray Sucharita, Sharma Sudhir, Kulkarni Girish Baburao, Rao Girish N, Mailankody Pooja, Garuda Butchi Raju, Bharadwaj Amit, Angra Monika, Ferriera Teresa, Sharma Ashish, Wilson Vinny P, Kuthiala Neha, Sharma Sakshi, Bhasin Ashu, Mukherjee Aprajita, Agarwal Ayush, Murali Suhas, Nilima Nilima, Srivastava M V Padma
Department of Neurology, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi, India.
Department of Neurology, Post Graduate Institute of Medical Education and Research, Chandigarh, India.
Ann Indian Acad Neurol. 2022 May-Jun;25(3):422-427. doi: 10.4103/aian.aian_1052_21. Epub 2022 Jun 24.
One of the major challenges is to deliver adequate health care in rural India, where more than two-thirds of India's population lives. There is a severe shortage of specialists in rural areas with one of the world's lowest physician/population ratios. There is only one neurologist per 1.25 million population. Stroke rehabilitation is virtually nonexistent in most district hospitals. Two innovative solutions include training physicians in district hospitals to diagnose and manage acute stroke ('Stroke physician model') and using a low-cost Telestroke model. We will be assessing the efficacy of these models through a cluster-randomized trial with a standard of care database maintained simultaneously in tertiary nodal centers with neurologists.
SMART INDIA is a multicenter, open-label cluster-randomized trial with the hospital as a unit of randomization. The study will include district hospitals from the different states of India. We plan to enroll 22 district hospitals where a general physician manages the emergency without the services of a neurologist. These units (hospitals) will be randomized into either of two interventions using computer-generated random sequences with allocation concealment. Blinding of patients and clinicians will not be possible. The outcome assessment will be conducted by the blinded central adjudication team. The study includes 12 expert centers involved in the Telestroke arm by providing neurologists and telerehabilitation round the clock for attending calls. These centers will also be the training hub for "stroke physicians" where they will be given intensive short-term training for the management of acute stroke. There will be a preintervention data collection (1 month), followed by the intervention model implementation (3 months).
The primary outcome will be the composite score (percentage) of performance of acute stroke care bundle assessed at 1 and 3 months after the intervention. The highest score (100%) will be achieved if all the eligible patients receive the standard stroke care bundle. The study will have an open-label extension for 3 more months.
SMART INDIA assesses whether the low-cost Telestroke model is superior to the stroke physician model in achieving acute stroke care delivery. The results of this study can be utilized in national programs for stroke and can be a role model for stroke care delivery in low- and middle-Income countries. (CTRI/2021/11/038196).
印度农村地区面临的主要挑战之一是提供充足的医疗保健服务,印度超过三分之二的人口居住在农村。农村地区专科医生严重短缺,医生与人口比例是世界最低之一。每125万人口中仅有一名神经科医生。在大多数地区医院,中风康复治疗几乎不存在。两种创新解决方案包括培训地区医院的医生诊断和管理急性中风(“中风医生模式”)以及采用低成本远程中风模式。我们将通过一项整群随机试验评估这些模式的疗效,同时在设有神经科医生的三级节点中心维护一个标准护理数据库。
“智能印度”是一项多中心、开放标签的整群随机试验,以医院作为随机分组单位。该研究将纳入印度不同邦的地区医院。我们计划招募22家地区医院,这些医院由普通医生在没有神经科医生服务的情况下处理急诊。这些单位(医院)将使用计算机生成的随机序列并采用分配隐藏法随机分为两种干预措施中的一种。患者和临床医生无法设盲。结局评估将由设盲的中央裁决小组进行。该研究包括12个专家中心参与远程中风组,这些中心通过提供神经科医生和全天候远程康复服务来接听电话。这些中心也将成为“中风医生”的培训中心,在这里他们将接受急性中风管理的强化短期培训。将进行干预前数据收集(1个月),随后实施干预模式(3个月)。
主要结局将是干预后1个月和3个月评估的急性中风护理套餐执行情况的综合评分(百分比)。如果所有符合条件的患者都接受标准中风护理套餐,将获得最高分(100%)。该研究将有一个为期3个月的开放标签扩展期。
“智能印度”评估低成本远程中风模式在实现急性中风护理方面是否优于中风医生模式。本研究结果可用于国家中风项目,并可为低收入和中等收入国家的中风护理提供范例。(CTRI/2021/11/038196)