Relationship between thread depth and fixation strength in cancellous bone screw.

BACKGROUND

Clarifying the effect of each parameter of screw design on its fixation strength is critical in the development of any type of screw. The purpose of this study was to clarify the relationship between the thread depth and fixation strength of metal screws for cancellous bone.

METHODS

Nine types of custom-made screws with the only changed variable being the thread depth were manufactured. Other elements were fixed at a major diameter of 4.5 mm, a thread region length of 15 mm, a pitch of 1.6 mm, and a thread width of 0.20 mm. The pull-out strength and insertion torque of each screw were measured for each of two foam-block densities (10 or 20 pcf). The correlation between the thread depth of the screw and the mechanical findings were investigated with single regression analysis.

RESULTS

Regardless of the foam-block density, the pull-out strength significantly increased as the thread depth increased from 0.1 mm to 0.4 mm; after that, the increase was more gradual (p < 0.01, respectively). The relationship between the thread depth and insertion torque was similar. In addition, the insertion torque tended to be more strongly affected by screw depth than the pull-out strength (2.6 times at 20 pcf and 1.4 times at 10 pcf).

CONCLUSIONS

The pull-out strength of 4.5-mm-diameter metal screws in a cancellous bone model was found to be biphasic, although linearly correlated with the change in screw depth in both phases. The boundary of the correlation was 0.4 mm regardless of the density of the bone model, with the effect of screw depth on pull-out strength beyond that being small in comparison.