Santos Jário, Bittencourt Ig, Reis Marcelo, Chalco Geiser, Isotani Seiji
Institute of Mathematics and Computer Science, University of São Paulo (ICMC-USP), CEP: 13566-590 São Carlos, SP Brazil.
Institute of Computer Science, University of Alagoas (UFAL), Maceió, Brazil, CEP: 57072-970 Maceió, AL Brazil.
Humanit Soc Sci Commun. 2022;9(1):249. doi: 10.1057/s41599-022-01220-6. Epub 2022 Jul 30.
According to the literature, educational technologies present several learning benefits to promote online education. However, there are several associated challenges, and some studies illustrate the limitations in elaborating educational technologies, called Design limitations. This aspect is responsible for unleashing various issues in the learning process, such as gender inequality, creating adverse effects on cognitive, motivational, and behavioral mediators, which opposes the fifth UN's Sustainable Development Goal. Therefore, many studies notice the harmful effects of stereotypes in educational technologies. These effects can be included in the design, like colors or other stereotyped elements, or how the activity is conducted. Based on this, the present study aimed to verify the predominance of color bias in educational technologies available on the WEB. This study developed a computational solution to calculate male and female color bias in the available educational technology web pages. The results suggest the prevalence of the development of educational technologies with a male color bias, with an imbalance among genders, without adequate customization for age groups. Furthermore, some environments, such as Computer Science, present a higher color bias for men when compared to women. Despite both scales being independent, results indicated interesting evidence of a substantial prevalence of colors associated with the male scale. According to the literature, this may be associated with dropout and lack of interest in female students, especially in sciences, technology, engineering, and mathematics domains.
根据文献记载,教育技术具有多种学习优势,有助于推动在线教育。然而,也存在一些相关挑战,一些研究阐述了教育技术存在的局限性,即所谓的设计局限。这方面会在学习过程中引发各种问题,比如性别不平等,对认知、动机和行为调节因素产生负面影响,这与联合国可持续发展目标的第五项相悖。因此,许多研究注意到教育技术中刻板印象的有害影响。这些影响可能体现在设计方面,如颜色或其他刻板元素,或者活动的开展方式上。基于此,本研究旨在验证网络上现有教育技术中颜色偏见的普遍性。本研究开发了一种计算方法,用于计算现有教育技术网页中男性和女性的颜色偏见。结果表明,存在男性颜色偏见的教育技术较为普遍,并存在性别失衡现象,且未针对不同年龄组进行适当定制。此外,与女性相比,计算机科学等一些领域对男性的颜色偏见更高。尽管两个量表相互独立,但结果显示了与男性量表相关的颜色普遍存在的有趣证据。根据文献记载,这可能与女学生辍学及缺乏兴趣有关,尤其是在科学、技术、工程和数学领域。