Department of Physical Therapy and Rehabilitation, Institute of Health Sciences, Istanbul Medipol University, Beykoz/İstanbul, Turkey.
Department of General Surgery, Faculty of Medicine, Istanbul Medipol University, Bağcılar/İstanbul, Turkey.
Eur J Cancer Care (Engl). 2022 Nov;31(6):e13685. doi: 10.1111/ecc.13685. Epub 2022 Aug 15.
To examine the reliability, quality and content of YouTube videos on exercises that can be performed after breast cancer (BC) surgery.
Videos selected from YouTube using the search terms 'shoulder exercise and BC surgery', 'arm exercise and BC surgery' and 'physiotherapy/physical therapy and BC surgery' were categorised as useful or misleading by a surgeon and a physiotherapist. The videos were analysed using the 5-point DISCERN scale for reliability, the Global Quality Scale for quality and a 10-item scale for comprehensiveness.
Of the 180 videos initially analysed, 82 were included in the study, and 42 (51.2%) were classified as having misleading information and 40(48.8%) as having useful information. The reliability, quality and content scores of the videos containing useful information were higher (p < 0.001). Most of the videos in the useful information group (80%) were uploaded by universities/professional organisations/physicians/physiotherapists, while the majority of those in the misleading information group (47.6%) were uploaded by websites providing independent healthcare information.
YouTube can be an important instrument to protect patients from musculoskeletal system complications after BC treatment and improve existing complications. Universities, physicians and physiotherapists should be encouraged to prepare more videos containing full and accurate information on this subject.
检查关于乳腺癌(BC)手术后可进行的锻炼的 YouTube 视频的可靠性、质量和内容。
使用“肩部锻炼和 BC 手术”、“手臂锻炼和 BC 手术”和“物理疗法/物理治疗和 BC 手术”等搜索词从 YouTube 上选择视频,由外科医生和物理治疗师将这些视频归类为有用或误导。使用可靠性的 5 点 DISCERN 量表、质量的全球质量量表和 10 项综合量表对视频进行分析。
最初分析的 180 个视频中,有 82 个被纳入研究,其中 42 个(51.2%)被归类为具有误导性信息,40 个(48.8%)具有有用信息。包含有用信息的视频的可靠性、质量和内容评分较高(p < 0.001)。有用信息组中的大多数视频(80%)是由大学/专业组织/医生/物理治疗师上传的,而误导性信息组中的大多数视频(47.6%)是由提供独立医疗保健信息的网站上传的。
YouTube 可以成为保护患者免受 BC 治疗后肌肉骨骼系统并发症和改善现有并发症的重要工具。应鼓励大学、医生和物理治疗师制作更多包含有关该主题的完整和准确信息的视频。