Waller T J, Kay H R, Spielman S R, Kutalek S P, Greenspan A M, Horowitz L N
J Am Coll Cardiol. 1987 Jul;10(1):83-9. doi: 10.1016/s0735-1097(87)80164-x.
Reports of the results of electrophysiologic testing of antiarrhythmic regimens have concentrated on inducibility of ventricular tachycardias during drug treatment. Many drug regimens, however, affect the tachycardia but fail to prevent its initiation. In this study, 258 patients who underwent serial electrophysiologic studies were followed up. The patients were divided into three groups on the basis of the results of electrophysiologic testing. Group 1 included patients in whom the initiation of ventricular tachycardia was prevented by the drug regimen. In groups 2 and 3 the ventricular tachycardia was still inducible with the discharge drug regimen. In group 2, the drug regimen demonstrated a beneficial response (that is, the tachycardia cycle length increased by greater than 100 ms and the tachycardia did not produce severe symptoms). In group 3, the regimen did not produce a beneficial response. During follow-up, recurrence of sustained ventricular tachycardia occurred in 7 (7%) of 103 group 1 patients but in 20 (39%) of 51 and 52 (50%) of 104 group 2 and 3 patients, respectively. However, the total mortality and sudden death mortality rates were substantially reduced in group 2 (12 and 4%, respectively) compared with group 3 (39 and 34%). In fact, the total mortality and sudden death mortality in groups 1 and 2 were not significantly different. Thus, under certain circumstances, a drug regimen that produces a beneficial response may be an acceptable clinical alternative, particularly when no regimen prevents induction of ventricular tachycardia.
抗心律失常治疗方案的电生理测试结果报告主要集中在药物治疗期间室性心动过速的诱发性。然而,许多药物治疗方案虽能影响心动过速,但无法预防其发作。在本研究中,对258例接受系列电生理研究的患者进行了随访。根据电生理测试结果将患者分为三组。第1组包括室性心动过速发作被药物治疗方案预防的患者。在第2组和第3组中,室性心动过速仍可被出院时的药物治疗方案诱发。在第2组中,药物治疗方案显示出有益反应(即心动过速周期长度增加超过100毫秒且心动过速未产生严重症状)。在第3组中,该方案未产生有益反应。随访期间,103例第1组患者中有7例(7%)发生持续性室性心动过速复发,而第2组51例患者中有20例(39%)、第3组104例患者中有52例(50%)发生复发。然而,与第3组(分别为39%和34%)相比,第2组的总死亡率和猝死死亡率大幅降低(分别为12%和4%)。事实上,第1组和第2组的总死亡率和猝死死亡率无显著差异。因此,在某些情况下,产生有益反应的药物治疗方案可能是一种可接受的临床选择,尤其是当没有治疗方案能预防室性心动过速诱发时。