Department of Clinical Psychology, Graduate School of Medical Sciences, Tottori University, 86 Nishi-cho, Yonago, 683-8503, Japan.
Department of Psychology, Graduate School of Humanities and Social Sciences, Hiroshima University, Hiroshima, Japan.
Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 2023 Nov;32(11):2209-2221. doi: 10.1007/s00787-022-02055-x. Epub 2022 Aug 19.
Some long-term outcomes for participants with selective mutism (SM) are elevated rates of phobic disorders, particularly social phobia, persistent communicative problems, and reduced self-esteem. However, data on the long-term outcomes of SM are scarce. In this study, by analyzing interpersonal anxiety, communication skills, and self-esteem among those who experienced SM and felt cured (SM-C-group: 30 females, 6 males, mean age 28.0, SD = 7.42, range 19-47 years), those who experienced SM and did not feel cured (SM-NC-group: 37 females, 4 males, mean age 27.4, SD = 7.24, age range 19-50 years), and those who had not experienced SM (Non-SM-group: 30 females, 30 males, mean age 26.4, SD = 7.62, age range: 20-48 years), we examined the long-term outcomes of SM and the factors that influence the feeling of being cured of SM. Results showed that the SM-C-group and SM-NC-groups had significantly higher interpersonal anxiety and significantly lower communication skills than the Non-SM-group. Moreover, the SM-C-group showed significantly lower interpersonal anxiety and significantly higher communication skills than the SM-NC-group. However, while there was no significant difference in self-esteem between the SM-C and SM-NCgroups, there was a significant difference between the SM-NC and Non-SM groups. The SM-C and SM-NC groups did not differ on the retrospective symptom load (SMQ-J), but did on the Current level of difficulty with speaking. The results of the logistic regression analysis predicted that communication skills and self-esteem did not influence the feeling of being cured of SM, but interpersonal anxiety and Current level of difficulty to speak did. Therefore, it is speculated that the intensity of this interpersonal anxiety and whether people with SM still felt difficulty in talking to others may have affected the feeling of being cured from SM.
一些选择性缄默症(SM)患者的长期预后是出现较高的恐惧症发病率,尤其是社交恐惧症,持续性交流问题和自尊心降低。然而,SM 的长期预后数据仍然缺乏。在这项研究中,我们通过分析经历过并感觉已治愈的 SM 患者(SM-C 组:30 名女性,6 名男性,平均年龄 28.0,标准差=7.42,年龄范围 19-47 岁)、经历过但未感觉已治愈的 SM 患者(SM-NC 组:37 名女性,4 名男性,平均年龄 27.4,标准差=7.24,年龄范围 19-50 岁)和未经历过 SM 的患者(非 SM 组:30 名女性,30 名男性,平均年龄 26.4,标准差=7.62,年龄范围 20-48 岁)的人际焦虑、交流技能和自尊心,来检验 SM 的长期预后,以及影响 SM 治愈感的因素。结果表明,SM-C 组和 SM-NC 组的人际焦虑显著高于非 SM 组,交流技能显著低于非 SM 组。而且,SM-C 组的人际焦虑显著低于 SM-NC 组,交流技能显著高于 SM-NC 组。然而,虽然 SM-C 组和 SM-NC 组的自尊心没有显著差异,但 SM-NC 组和非 SM 组的自尊心有显著差异。SM-C 组和 SM-NC 组在回顾性症状负荷(SMQ-J)方面没有差异,但在当前说话困难程度方面有差异。逻辑回归分析的结果预测,交流技能和自尊心不会影响 SM 的治愈感,而人际焦虑和当前说话困难程度会影响。因此,据推测,这种人际焦虑的强度以及 SM 患者是否仍感到与他人交谈困难,可能会影响他们对 SM 治愈的感觉。