Friedman A S, Glickman N W
J Nerv Ment Dis. 1987 Jul;175(7):419-24. doi: 10.1097/00005053-198707000-00005.
The relationship to treatment outcome (as measured by the National Institute of Drug Abuse Client-Oriented Data Acquisition Process [NIDA-CODAP] Reasons for Discharge classification) of specific characteristics and elements of 22 drug-free residential programs for adolescents is reported. Admission and discharge data were obtained from NIDA-CODAP on 2,532 adolescents in the 22 programs. A partial cross-validation study was conducted by analyzing separately for two annual client subsamples. The program, not the individual client, was the unit of analysis. When three differences between programs in their client populations were "partialed out" the following characteristics of programs were found to predict positively to outcome (a lower treatment failure rate) to a statistically significant degree: the number of years that the counselors had worked in the programs; the number of volunteer staff in direct service (client contact); the proportion of clients receiving bodily and mental relaxation techniques: the counselors' perceptions that their programs accept or encourage relatively more spontaneous personal expressiveness, including expression of anger by clients, in staff-client relationships, but encourage less client "autonomy" (to be self-sufficient and independent with regard to making their own decisions); the counselors report that providing practical assistance in solving clients' real-life problems is useful. There was a high degree of replication of these findings across the two annual subsamples of clients. These findings for adolescents in residential programs are compared with findings reported in a parallel study of treatment outcome for adolescents in outpatient programs.
本文报告了22个青少年戒毒寄宿项目的特定特征和要素与治疗结果(以美国国立药物滥用研究所面向客户的数据采集流程[NIDA - CODAP]出院原因分类来衡量)之间的关系。从NIDA - CODAP获取了这22个项目中2532名青少年的入院和出院数据。通过分别对两个年度客户子样本进行分析,开展了一项部分交叉验证研究。分析单位是项目,而非个体客户。当项目在其客户群体中的三个差异被“排除”后,发现项目的以下特征对结果(较低的治疗失败率)有显著的正向预测作用:咨询师在项目中工作的年数;直接服务(与客户接触)的志愿者工作人员数量;接受身心放松技巧的客户比例;咨询师认为他们的项目在员工 - 客户关系中接受或鼓励相对更多的自然个人表达,包括客户表达愤怒,但鼓励客户“自主性”(在做自己的决定方面自给自足和独立)较少;咨询师报告称,在解决客户现实生活问题方面提供实际帮助是有用的。这些发现在两个年度客户子样本中高度一致。将寄宿项目中青少年的这些发现与门诊项目中青少年治疗结果的平行研究报告中的发现进行了比较。