Département de psychologie, Université de Montréal, Montréal, QC, Canada.
Faculty of Psychology and Neuroscience, Maastricht University, Maastricht, the Netherlands.
Brain Res. 2022 Nov 1;1794:148057. doi: 10.1016/j.brainres.2022.148057. Epub 2022 Aug 18.
The present study aimed at investigating the long-term stability and test-retest reliability of neuronavigated transcranial magnetic stimulation (nTMS) measures of cortical excitability, inhibition, and facilitation in the primary motor cortex. To fulfill these aims, thirty-one healthy adults underwent four nTMS sessions, over an average one-month period. Stability and test-retest reliability statistics were computed and analyzed to produce smallest real difference statistics, which indicate the absolute variation in a measurement that is likely to be the result of error (randomness). Excellent reliability was found for resting motor thresholds, which reflect baseline neuronal excitability. Good reliability statistics were found for input/output curve measurements, which reflect the excitability of a highly plastic neuronal population. Using the slope of mean amplitudes throughout the input/output curve or the stimulator intensity required to elicit motor evoked potentials of 1 mV presented good to excellent measurement reliability for global cortical excitability indexing, compared to mean MEP at a given intensity. Overall, this methodological study provides useful and novel information on transcranial magnetic stimulation interventions by providing smallest real difference statistics that inform on potential response thresholds across time, contributing to the validation of these measurements as clinical monitoring tools across time.
本研究旨在探究经颅磁刺激(TMS)引导下皮质兴奋性、抑制性和易化作用的皮质兴奋性、抑制性和易化作用的长期稳定性和重测信度。为了实现这些目标,31 名健康成年人接受了 4 次 nTMS 治疗,平均间隔为一个月。我们计算并分析了稳定性和重测信度的统计数据,以产生最小真实差异统计数据,该数据表示测量值中可能因误差(随机性)而产生的绝对变化。静息运动阈值的可靠性很好,这反映了基线神经元的兴奋性。输入/输出曲线测量的可靠性也很好,这反映了高度可塑的神经元群体的兴奋性。与给定强度下的平均 MEPs 相比,使用输入/输出曲线中的平均幅度斜率或引起 1 mV 运动诱发电位所需的刺激器强度来进行全局皮质兴奋性指标评估,具有良好到极好的测量可靠性。总体而言,通过提供潜在反应阈值随时间变化的最小真实差异统计数据,本方法学研究为经颅磁刺激干预提供了有用且新颖的信息,为这些测量值作为随时间推移的临床监测工具的有效性提供了支持。