Department of Dermatology and Allergy, Technical University of Munich, School of Medicine, Munich, Germany.
Institute of General Practice and Health Services Research, School of Medicine, Technical University of Munich, Munich, Germany.
Med Educ Online. 2022 Dec;27(1):2114131. doi: 10.1080/10872981.2022.2114131.
The COVID-19 pandemic forced a rapid shift to digital strategies including e-exams in medical schools. However, there are significant concerns, predominately from student perspectives, and further data is required to successfully establish e-assessment in the medical curricula. The objective of the study was to examine medical students' perceptions, concerns, and needs regarding e-assessment to establish a comprehensive e-exam based on these and previous findings and to evaluate its effectiveness in terms of examinee perceptions and further needs. During the 2021 summer term, a cross-sectional study using qualitative and quantitative methods was conducted among all 1077 students at the School of Medicine, Technical University of Munich. They were asked to provide information regarding their characteristics, preferred exam format, e-assessment perception, concerns, and needs in an online questionnaire. Based on these findings, a pilot e-exam including an e-exam preparation for the students were established and subsequently evaluated among 125 pilot e-exam examinees under study consideration via an online-questionnaire. Of the 317 pre-exam participants (73.2% female), 70.3% preferred in-person exams and showed concerns about the technological framework, privacy, and examination requirements. Qualitative analysis showed that these concerns lead to additional exam stress and fear of failure. The 34 (79.4% female) participants who participated in the evaluation survey showed a significantly more positive e-exam perception. The fairness of the platform, the independence from an internet connection, the organization including the e-exam preparation, and the consideration of participant needs were discussed as particularly positive in the open-ended comments. In both surveys, participants requested uniform platforms and processes for all subjects. This study provides evidence for a positive, complementary role of student participation in a successful e-exam implementation. Furthermore, when establishing an e-exam format in the medical curricula, e-exam training, equal accessibility, availability offline, and all-round fairness should be considered.
COVID-19 大流行迫使医学教育迅速转向数字战略,包括医学院的电子考试。然而,从学生的角度来看,存在着重大的担忧,并且需要进一步的数据来成功地在医学课程中建立电子评估。本研究的目的是检查医学生对电子评估的看法、担忧和需求,以便根据这些和以前的发现建立一个全面的电子考试,并根据考生的看法和进一步的需求评估其效果。在 2021 年夏季学期,对慕尼黑工业大学医学院的所有 1077 名学生进行了一项使用定性和定量方法的横断面研究。他们被要求在在线问卷中提供有关他们的特征、首选考试形式、电子评估认知、担忧和需求的信息。基于这些发现,为学生建立了一个试点电子考试,并在研究考虑下,通过在线问卷,在 125 名试点电子考试考生中对其进行了评估。在 317 名参加预考试的参与者中(73.2%为女性),70.3%的人更喜欢面对面考试,并对技术框架、隐私和考试要求表示担忧。定性分析表明,这些担忧会导致额外的考试压力和对失败的恐惧。34 名(79.4%为女性)参加评估调查的参与者对电子考试的看法明显更为积极。参与者在开放性评论中讨论了平台的公平性、对互联网连接的独立性、包括电子考试准备在内的组织以及对参与者需求的考虑,认为这些是特别积极的方面。在这两个调查中,参与者都要求为所有科目提供统一的平台和流程。本研究为学生参与成功实施电子考试的积极、互补作用提供了证据。此外,在医学课程中建立电子考试形式时,应考虑电子考试培训、平等的可及性、离线可用性和全面的公平性。