Senior Physiotherapist, Central Remedial Clinic, Clontarf, Dublin, Ireland.
School of Physiotherapy, Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland University of Medicine and Health Sciences, Dublin, Ireland.
Disabil Rehabil. 2023 Aug;45(17):2796-2807. doi: 10.1080/09638288.2022.2110617. Epub 2022 Aug 23.
PURPOSE: To determine if Pilates-based exercise classes could be feasible and effective in changing gait kinematics and balance in ambulant children with Cerebral Palsy (CP). MATERIALS AND METHODS: A single-blind multi-centre randomised controlled trial compared a four-week, twice-weekly Pilates-based exercise class to a usual exercise control, for ambulant children with CP. Clinical outcome measures were three-dimensional trunk and lower limb kinematics during walking on level ground, uneven ground and crossing an obstacle; and clinical balance measures. Feasibility outcomes were adherence and enjoyment. RESULTS: Forty-six children (29 male, mean age 10 years 8 months (range 7-17 years), 23 per group) participated. After the four-week intervention, there were no significant between-group differences in trunk or lower limb gait kinematics. Differences were detected in Berg Balance Scale (1.38 points, 95% CI 0.58-2.18) and Functional Walking Test (1.40 points, 95% CI 0.58-2.22), but they were less than the minimum clinically important difference and therefore clinically insignificant. Median class attendance was 5/8 classes. CONCLUSION: Pilates-based exercises did not change lower limb or trunk kinematics during walking in children with CP and had a clinically insignificant impact on balance. Lower than anticipated adherence prompts consideration of more flexible delivery of future interventions. Implications for RehabilitationAmbulant children with CP can experience impairment of trunk control, negatively impacting balance and gait.In this study, Pilates-based exercise classes did not change kinematics of the trunk or lower limbs during walking and led to negligible improvement in functional balance.Children did not manage to do their Home Exercise Programme, indicating that Pilates-based exercise should be delivered within supervised practice.Children missed on average one in three classes due to unforeseen circumstances, so this should be anticipated when planning group classes.
目的:探讨基于普拉提的运动课程是否能改变脑瘫患儿的步态运动学和平衡能力。 材料与方法:一项单盲多中心随机对照试验比较了为期四周、每周两次的基于普拉提的运动课程与常规运动对照在脑瘫患儿中的效果。临床结局指标为平地、不平地面和过障碍物行走时的三维躯干和下肢运动学;临床平衡指标。可行性指标为依从性和趣味性。 结果:46 名儿童(29 名男性,平均年龄 10 岁 8 个月(7-17 岁),每组 23 名)参与了研究。经过四周的干预,两组间躯干或下肢步态运动学无显著差异。但在 Berg 平衡量表(1.38 分,95%CI 0.58-2.18)和功能性步行测试(1.40 分,95%CI 0.58-2.22)中存在差异,但差异小于最小临床重要差异,因此无临床意义。中位数班级出勤率为 5/8 节课。 结论:基于普拉提的运动并没有改变脑瘫患儿行走时的下肢或躯干运动学,对平衡的影响也没有临床意义。低于预期的依从性提示未来干预措施的交付方式应更加灵活。 对康复的启示:脑瘫患儿可能会出现躯干控制障碍,从而对平衡和步态产生负面影响。在这项研究中,基于普拉提的运动课程并没有改变脑瘫患儿行走时的躯干或下肢运动学,对功能性平衡的改善作用可以忽略不计。 患儿未能完成家庭运动计划,表明普拉提运动应该在监督练习中进行。 由于意外情况,患儿平均缺课三分之一,因此在计划小组课程时应考虑到这一点。