Lyre Holger
Chair for Theoretical Philosophy, University of Magdeburg, Magdeburg, Germany.
Neurosci Conscious. 2022 Aug 23;2022(1):niac012. doi: 10.1093/nc/niac012. eCollection 2022.
The program of "neurophenomenal structuralism" is presented as an agenda for a genuine structuralist neuroscience of consciousness that seeks to understand specific phenomenal experiences as strictly relational affairs. The paper covers a broad range of topics. It starts from considerations about neural change detection and relational coding that motivate a solution of the Newman problem of the brain in terms of spatiotemporal relations. Next, phenomenal quality spaces and their Q-structures are discussed. Neurophenomenal structuralism proclaims a homomorphic mapping of the structures of self-organized neural maps in the brain onto Q-structures, and it will be demonstrated how this leads to a new and special version of structural representationalism about phenomenal content. A methodological implication of neurophenomenal structuralism is that it proposes measurement procedures that focus on the relationships between different stimuli (as, for instance, similarity ratings or representational geometry methods). Finally, it will be shown that neurophenomenal structuralism also has strong philosophical implications, as it leads to holism about phenomenal experiences and serves to reject inverted qualia scenarios.
“神经现象结构主义”计划被视为真正的意识结构主义神经科学的议程,该神经科学试图将特定的现象体验理解为严格的关系事务。本文涵盖了广泛的主题。它始于对神经变化检测和关系编码的思考,这些思考促使从时空关系的角度解决大脑的纽曼问题。接下来,讨论了现象质量空间及其Q结构。神经现象结构主义宣称大脑中自组织神经图的结构与Q结构之间存在同态映射,并将证明这如何导致关于现象内容的结构表征主义的一种新的特殊版本。神经现象结构主义的一个方法论含义是,它提出了侧重于不同刺激之间关系的测量程序(例如相似性评级或表征几何方法)。最后,将表明神经现象结构主义也具有强烈的哲学含义,因为它导致了现象体验的整体论,并有助于拒绝颠倒的感受质情景。