Higginbotham Gerald D, Sears David O, Goldstein Lauren
Frank Batten School of Leadership and Public Policy, University of Virginia.
Department of Psychology, University of California, Los Angeles.
J Exp Psychol Gen. 2023 Feb;152(2):410-424. doi: 10.1037/xge0001275. Epub 2022 Aug 25.
Historical evidence suggests that White Americans' support for gun rights (i.e., opposition to gun control) is challenged by Black Americans exercising their legal rights to guns (e.g., The Black Panther Party and the Mulford Act of 1967). Here, we examined two empirical questions. First, we tested whether White Americans implicitly racialize gun rights as "White." In a preregistered study employing a novel IAT, racially resentful White Americans indirectly associated gun rights with White (and not Black) people. Moreover, this association was not primarily based in partisanship. Racial resentment overwhelmed the effect of party identification in explaining this association (Study 1). Given racial resentment typically predicts stronger support for gun rights (Filindra & Kaplan, 2015; O'Brien et al., 2013), we next examined whether Black legal gun ownership undermines gun rights support among racially resentful White Americans across two studies (total = 773), including a nationally representative sample of White partisans. In both studies, racially resentful White Americans expressed less support for a gun right (i.e., concealed-carry) when informed that Black (vs. White) Americans showed greater utilization of the gun right (Studies 2 and 3). Study 3 provided initial evidence suggesting that the observed reduced support is more closely linked to concerns about identity than security. Overall, these results support that Black legal gun ownership can reduce opposition to gun control among gun rights' most entrenched advocates. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2023 APA, all rights reserved).
历史证据表明,美国白人对枪支权利的支持(即反对枪支管制)受到非裔美国人行使其合法持枪权利行为的挑战(例如黑豹党和1967年的《穆尔福德法案》)。在此,我们研究了两个实证问题。首先,我们测试了美国白人是否会将枪支权利隐含地“种族化”为“白人的权利”。在一项预先注册的研究中,我们采用了一种新颖的内隐联想测验(IAT),结果发现,心怀种族怨恨的美国白人将枪支权利与白人(而非黑人)间接联系在一起。此外,这种关联并非主要基于党派立场。在解释这种关联时,种族怨恨压倒了党派认同的影响(研究1)。鉴于种族怨恨通常预示着对枪支权利的更强支持(菲林德拉和卡普兰,2015年;奥布赖恩等人,2013年),我们接下来在两项研究(总计773人)中考察了黑人合法持枪是否会削弱心怀种族怨恨的美国白人对枪支权利的支持,其中一项研究的样本为具有全国代表性的白人党派人士。在两项研究中,当得知非裔美国人(与白人相比)对枪支权利的利用率更高时,心怀种族怨恨的美国白人对一项枪支权利(即隐蔽携带枪支)的支持度降低(研究2和研究3)。研究3提供了初步证据,表明观察到的支持度降低与身份认同方面的担忧比与安全方面的担忧联系更为紧密。总体而言,这些结果支持了黑人合法持枪能够减少枪支权利最坚定拥护者对枪支管制的反对这一观点。(《心理学文摘数据库记录》(c)2023美国心理学会,保留所有权利)