Observational study on associations between resilience indicators based on daily milk yield in first lactation and lifetime profitability.

Resilience is the ability of cows to be minimally affected by disturbances, such as pathogens, heat waves, and changes in feed quality, or to quickly recover. Obvious advantages of resilience are good animal welfare and easy and pleasant management for farmers. Furthermore, economic effects are also expected, but these remain to be determined. The goal of this study was to investigate the association between resilience and lifetime gross margin, using indicators of resilience calculated from fluctuations in daily milk yield using an observational study. Resilience indicators and lifetime gross margin were calculated for 1,325 cows from 21 herds. These cows were not alive anymore and, therefore, had complete lifetime data available for many traits. The resilience indicators were the natural log-transformed variance (LnVar) and the lag-1 autocorrelation (r) of daily milk yield deviations from cow-specific lactation curves in parity 1. Good resilience is indicated by low LnVar (small yield response to disturbances) and low r (quick yield recovery to baseline). Lifetime gross margin was calculated as the sum of all revenues minus the sum of all costs throughout life. Included revenues were from milk, calf value, and slaughter of the cow. Included costs were from feed, rearing, insemination, management around calving, disease treatments, and destruction in case of death on farm. Feed intake was unknown and, therefore, lifetime feed costs had to be estimated based on milk yield records. The association of each resilience indicator with lifetime gross margin, and also with the underlying revenues and costs, was investigated using analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) models. Mean daily milk yield in first lactation, herd, and year of birth were included as covariates and factors. Natural log-transformed variance had a significantly negative association with lifetime gross margin, which means that cows with stable milk yield (low LnVar, good resilience) in parity 1 generated on average a higher lifetime gross margin than cows that had the same milk yield level but with more fluctuations. The association with lifetime gross margin could be mainly attributed to higher lifetime milk revenues for cows with low LnVar, due to a longer lifespan. Unlike LnVar, r was not significantly associated with lifetime gross margin or any of the underlying lifetime costs and revenues. However, it was significantly associated with yearly treatment costs, which is important for ease of management. In conclusion, the importance of resilience for total profit generated by a cow at the end of life was confirmed by the significant association of LnVar with lifetime gross margin, although effects of differences in feed efficiency between resilient and less resilient cows remain to be studied. The economic advantage can be mainly ascribed to benefits of long lifespan.