Barba Patrick, Stramiello Joshua A, Nardone Zachary, Walsh-Blackmore Seth, Nation Javan, Ignacio Romeo, Magit Anthony
University of California San Diego School of Medicine. La Jolla, CA, USA.
University of California San Diego Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery. San Diego, CA, USA.
Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol. 2022 Nov;162:111291. doi: 10.1016/j.ijporl.2022.111291. Epub 2022 Aug 22.
Multi-level fall (MLF) accounts for 26.5%-37.7% of traumatic pediatric basilar skull fractures (BSFs). There is a dearth of information concerning recommendations for work-up, diagnosis, treatment, and otolaryngological follow-up of pediatric basilar skull fractures secondary to MLFs. Through a systematic literature review and retrospective review of an institution's trauma experience, we sought to identify clinical findings among pediatric MLF patients that indicate the need for otolaryngological follow-up.
A two-researcher team following the PRISMA guidelines performed a systematic literature review. PubMed, Web of Science, and EBSCO databases were searched August 16th 2020 and again on November 20th 2021 for English language articles published after 1980 using search terms Pediatric AND (fall OR "multi level fall" OR "fall from height") AND ("basilar fracture" OR "basilar skull fracture" OR "skull base fracture" OR "skull fracture"). Simultaneously, an institutional trauma database and retrospective chart review was performed for all patients under age 18 who presented with a MLF to a pediatric tertiary care center between 2007 and 2018.
168 publications were identified and 13 articles reporting pediatric basilar skull fracture data and MLF as a mechanism of injury were selected for review. MLF is the most common etiology of BSF, accounting for 26.5-37.7% of pediatric BSFs. In the retrospective review, there were 180 cases of BSF from MLF in the study period (4.2%). BSF and fall height were significantly associated (p < 0.001), as well as presence of a CSF leak and fall height (p = 0.02), intracranial hemorrhage (ICH) (p = 0.047), and BSF fracture type (p < 0.001). However, when stratified by age, these associations were only present in the younger group. Of those with non-temporal bone BSFs (n = 71), children with hemotympanum (n = 7) were approximately 18 times more likely (RR 18.3, 95% CI 1.89 to 177.02) than children without hemotympanum (n = 64) to have hearing loss at presentation (28.6% vs. 1.6% of patients).
MLF is the most common cause of pediatric basilar skull fractures. However, there is limited information on the appropriate work-up or otolaryngologic follow-up for this mechanism of injury. Our retrospective review suggests fall height is predictive for BSF, ICH, and CSF leak in younger children. Also, children with non-temporal bone BSFs and hemotympanum may represent a significant population requiring otolaryngology follow-up.
多级坠落(MLF)导致的创伤性小儿颅底骨折(BSF)占26.5%-37.7%。关于继发于MLF的小儿颅底骨折的检查、诊断、治疗及耳鼻喉科随访建议的信息匮乏。通过系统的文献综述及对某机构创伤经验的回顾性分析,我们试图确定小儿MLF患者中表明需要进行耳鼻喉科随访的临床发现。
一个由两名研究人员组成的团队遵循PRISMA指南进行了系统的文献综述。于2020年8月16日及2021年11月20日在PubMed、科学网和EBSCO数据库中检索1980年以后发表的英文文章,检索词为“小儿”且(“坠落”或“多级坠落”或“高处坠落”)且(“基底骨折”或“颅底骨折”或“颅底骨折”或“颅骨骨折”)。同时,对2007年至2018年间因MLF就诊于某小儿三级护理中心的所有18岁以下患者的机构创伤数据库进行回顾性图表分析。
共识别出168篇出版物,选择了13篇报告小儿颅底骨折数据及以MLF作为损伤机制的文章进行综述。MLF是BSF最常见的病因,占小儿BSF的26.5%-37.7%。在回顾性分析中,研究期间有180例MLF导致的BSF(占4.2%)。BSF与坠落高度显著相关(p<0.001),脑脊液漏的存在与坠落高度(p=0.02)、颅内出血(ICH)(p=0.047)及BSF骨折类型(p<0.001)也显著相关。然而,按年龄分层时,这些关联仅在较年轻组中存在。在非颞骨BSF患者(n=71)中,有血鼓室的儿童(n=7)出现听力损失的可能性(RR 18.3,95%CI 1.89至177.02)比无血鼓室的儿童(n=64)高约18倍(分别为28.6%和1.6%的患者)。
MLF是小儿颅底骨折最常见的原因。然而,关于这种损伤机制的适当检查或耳鼻喉科随访的信息有限。我们的回顾性分析表明,坠落高度可预测年幼儿童的BSF、ICH和脑脊液漏。此外,非颞骨BSF且有血鼓室的儿童可能是需要进行耳鼻喉科随访的重要人群。