Scientific Institute of Public Service, Environmental-Health Unit, Rue du Chéra 200, B-4000, Liège, Belgium.
FPS Health, Food Chain Safety and Environment, Ecotoxicology Unit from Service Plant Protection and Fertilising Products, 5/2 Avenue Galilée, B-1210, Brussels, Belgium.
Environ Pollut. 2022 Nov 1;312:120028. doi: 10.1016/j.envpol.2022.120028. Epub 2022 Aug 26.
Eighty eight adult gardeners and their relatives volunteered to provide urine and blood samples for a human biomonitoring survey among users of one of the biggest allotment garden from Wallonia, showing high trace metal(oid) concentrations in soils. The purpose was to determine if environmental levels of lead (Pb), cadmium (Cd) and arsenic (As) led to concentrations of potential health concern in the study population. Blood and urine biomarkers were compared to reference and intervention cut-off values selected from the literature. The study population exhibited (i) moderately high blood lead levels with median value of 23.1 μg/L, (ii) high urinary concentrations of speciated As (inorganic arsenic and its metabolites) with a median value of 7.17 μg/g.cr., i.e. twice the median values usually observed in general populations, and (iii) very high Cd levels in urine with a median value of 1.23 μg/L, in the range of 95th-97.5th percentiles measured in general adult populations. Biomarker levels in the study population were also mostly above those measured in adults from local populations living on contaminated soils, as reported in the current literature. All biomarkers of Pb, Cd and As showed weak to strong statistically significant correlations, pointing towards a joint environmental source to these three contaminants as being at least partially responsible for the high exposure levels observed. Urine and blood biomarkers show statistically significant associations with variables related to individual characteristics (age, smoking status, …) and Pb domestic sources (Pb pipes, cosmetics, …) but involves also behavioral and consuming habits related to gardening activities on the contaminated allotment garden. At such levels, owing to co-exposure and additive effects of Cd, As and Pb regarding renal toxicity known from literature, the study strongly suggests that this population of gardeners is at risk with respect to chronic kidney diseases.
88 名成年园丁及其亲属自愿提供尿液和血液样本,参与来自瓦隆大区最大的一个分配花园的用户的人体生物监测调查,该花园土壤中的痕量金属(类)浓度很高。目的是确定环境铅 (Pb)、镉 (Cd) 和砷 (As) 水平是否导致研究人群中潜在健康问题的浓度。血液和尿液生物标志物与文献中选择的参考和干预截止值进行了比较。研究人群表现出 (i) 血液铅水平中度偏高,中位数为 23.1μg/L,(ii) 尿液中砷(无机砷及其代谢物)的浓度很高,中位数为 7.17μg/g.cr,即通常在一般人群中观察到的中位数的两倍,以及 (iii) 尿液中 Cd 水平非常高,中位数为 1.23μg/L,在一般成年人群中测量的第 95-97.5 百分位范围内。研究人群中的生物标志物水平也大多高于当前文献中报道的生活在受污染土壤上的当地人群中成年人所测量的水平。Pb、Cd 和 As 的所有生物标志物均显示出弱到强的统计学显著相关性,表明这三种污染物的共同环境来源至少部分是导致观察到的高暴露水平的原因。尿液和血液生物标志物与与个体特征(年龄、吸烟状况等)和 Pb 家庭来源(Pb 管、化妆品等)相关的变量以及与在受污染的分配花园进行园艺活动相关的行为和消费习惯呈现出统计学显著关联。在这种水平下,由于 Cd、As 和 Pb 的共同暴露和文献中已知的对肾脏毒性的加性效应,该研究强烈表明,这群园丁存在慢性肾病风险。