De Rom Margot, Szmalec Arnaud, Van Reybroeck Marie
Psychological Sciences Research Institute, Université de Louvain, Louvain, Belgium.
Read Writ. 2023;36(5):1283-1318. doi: 10.1007/s11145-022-10337-8. Epub 2022 Aug 23.
Individual differences in reading performance between children appear from the onset of literacy acquisition. One possible explanation for this variability is the influence of inhibition in reading ability, a topic that has received very little research attention. Nevertheless, children often make guessing errors characterized by replacing a word with an orthographic neighbor, possibly linked to failing inhibition. The present study aims to evaluate the role of inhibition during word and sentence reading and compare its effects in spoken and motor tasks. Participants comprised 25 children in Grades 2 and 3 (M = 8; 2). The children performed five inhibition tasks in reading (words, sentences), spoken (words, sentences) and motor modalities. Within the two reading tasks, inhibition demands were assessed using pairs of orthographic neighbors for which the frequency was manipulated. Accuracy, types of errors, latency, and response times were measured. GLMM analyses demonstrated that children were sensitive to the inhibitory demands of both spoken tasks and of the sentence reading task regarding accuracy, latency, and response times. Indeed, children made more mistakes and were slower when inhibitory demands were augmented. They also made more guessing errors in the word reading task. No such inhibitory effect was found in the motor task. Moreover, correlational analyses revealed that children who showed better inhibitory skills were able to read words and texts more accurately. These findings suggest that children need to utilize inhibitory resources when processing words or sentences and that these inhibitory skills are involved in overall reading ability.
儿童在阅读表现上的个体差异从识字学习开始就显现出来。对于这种变异性的一种可能解释是抑制对阅读能力的影响,这一主题很少受到研究关注。然而,儿童经常会出现以用一个正字法相近的词替换另一个词为特征的猜测错误,这可能与抑制失败有关。本研究旨在评估抑制在单词和句子阅读过程中的作用,并比较其在口语和运动任务中的效果。参与者包括25名二、三年级的儿童(平均年龄 = 8岁2个月)。这些儿童在阅读(单词、句子)、口语(单词、句子)和运动模态下完成了五项抑制任务。在两项阅读任务中,使用频率被操纵的正字法相近词对来评估抑制需求。测量了准确性、错误类型、潜伏期和反应时间。广义线性混合模型分析表明,在准确性、潜伏期和反应时间方面,儿童对口语任务和句子阅读任务的抑制需求都很敏感。事实上,当抑制需求增加时,儿童会犯更多错误且速度更慢。他们在单词阅读任务中也会犯更多猜测错误。在运动任务中未发现这种抑制作用。此外,相关分析表明,表现出更好抑制技能的儿童能够更准确地阅读单词和文本。这些发现表明,儿童在处理单词或句子时需要利用抑制资源,并且这些抑制技能与整体阅读能力有关。