Flemming Donald J, White Carissa, Fox Edward, Fanburg-Smith Julie, Cochran Eric
Department of Radiology, Penn State Health Milton S. Hershey Medical Center, 500 University Drive H066, Hershey, PA, 17033, USA.
Department of Orthopaedics, Penn State Health Milton S. Hershey Medical Center, Hershey, PA, USA.
Skeletal Radiol. 2023 Mar;52(3):493-503. doi: 10.1007/s00256-022-04166-7. Epub 2022 Sep 1.
The objective of this paper is to explore sources of diagnostic error in musculoskeletal oncology and potential strategies for mitigating them using case examples. As musculoskeletal tumors are often obvious, the diagnostic errors in musculoskeletal oncology are frequently cognitive. In our experience, the most encountered cognitive biases in musculoskeletal oncologic imaging are as follows: (1) anchoring bias, (2) premature closure, (3) hindsight bias, (4) availability bias, and (5) alliterative bias. Anchoring bias results from failing to adjust an early impression despite receiving additional contrary information. Premature closure is the cognitive equivalent of "satisfaction of search." Hindsight bias occurs when we retrospectively overestimate the likelihood of correctly interpreting the examination prospectively. In availability bias, the radiologist judges the probability of a diagnosis based on which diagnosis is most easily recalled. Finally, alliterative bias occurs when a prior radiologist's impression overly influences the diagnostic thinking of another radiologist on a subsequent exam. In addition to cognitive biases, it is also important for radiologists to acknowledge their feelings when making a diagnosis to recognize positive and negative impact of affect on decision making. While errors decrease with radiologist experience, the lack of application of medical knowledge is often the primary source of error rather than a deficiency of knowledge, emphasizing the need to foster clinical reasoning skills and assist cognition. Possible solutions for reducing error exist at both the individual and the system level and include (1) improvement in knowledge and experience, (2) improvement in clinical reasoning and decision-making skills, and (3) improvement in assisting cognition.
本文的目的是通过实例探讨肌肉骨骼肿瘤学诊断错误的来源以及减轻这些错误的潜在策略。由于肌肉骨骼肿瘤通常较为明显,肌肉骨骼肿瘤学中的诊断错误往往是认知性的。根据我们的经验,肌肉骨骼肿瘤影像学中最常遇到的认知偏差如下:(1)锚定偏差,(2)过早闭合,(3)后见之明偏差,(4)可得性偏差,以及(5)首字母重复偏差。锚定偏差是指尽管收到了额外的相反信息,但仍未能调整早期印象。过早闭合在认知上等同于“搜索满意”。后见之明偏差是指我们在回顾时高估了前瞻性正确解读检查结果的可能性。在可得性偏差中,放射科医生根据最容易回忆起的诊断来判断诊断的可能性。最后,当先前放射科医生的印象过度影响另一位放射科医生在后续检查中的诊断思维时,就会出现首字母重复偏差。除了认知偏差外,放射科医生在做出诊断时认识到情感对决策的积极和消极影响也很重要。虽然错误会随着放射科医生经验的增加而减少,但医学知识应用的缺乏往往是错误的主要来源,而不是知识的不足,这强调了培养临床推理技能和辅助认知的必要性。减少错误的可能解决方案存在于个人和系统层面,包括(1)知识和经验的提升,(2)临床推理和决策技能的提升,以及(3)辅助认知的提升。