University of York, Heslington, York YO10 5DD, UK.
Med Probl Perform Art. 2022 Sep;37(3):200-206. doi: 10.21091/mppa.2022.3023.
Musician's focal dystonia (MFD) is a painless, task-specific neurological movement disorder that impairs fine motor control when playing an instrument. The pathophysiology is not fully understood, and while the available treatment strategies can help with improving motor control, they are rarely able to fully and reliably rehabilitate playing skills. Recent studies suggest that apart from genetic factors, maladaptive neuroplasticity, and the repetitive nature of the instrumental technique, psychosocial, psychological, and behavioural factors might also play a role in the onset of MFD. However, the presence of some of these risk factors is supported primarily by anecdotal evidence, with only a few aspects examined empirically. To explore this area further, 14 semi-structured interviews were conducted with a convenience sample of practitioners (8 medical professionals and 6 musician-coaches) who frequently treated MFD sufferers. Throughout their career, these participants are estimated to have interacted with more than 2,000 musicians with MFD, creating a large, indirect sample. A detailed patient profile emerged from the data with three main components: 1) the negative impact of social environments, including traumatic experiences and low quality of instrumental teaching; 2) a perfectionist, anxious, overly sensitive, and acquiescent personality type; and 3) obsessive, controlling, and inadequate practice behaviours. Participants stated MFD needs to be treated holistically and that neglecting these aspects during treatment could jeopardise rehabilitation. Further objective, controlled research trials are needed to describe these factors in detail, quantify their potential impact as risk factors, and understand how they might hinder therapy.
音乐家原发性肌张力障碍(MFD)是一种无痛性、特定于任务的神经运动障碍,当演奏乐器时会损害精细运动控制。其病理生理学尚未完全清楚,虽然现有的治疗策略有助于改善运动控制,但很少能够完全可靠地恢复演奏技能。最近的研究表明,除了遗传因素、适应不良的神经可塑性和乐器技术的重复性之外,心理社会、心理和行为因素也可能在 MFD 的发病中起作用。然而,这些风险因素的存在主要得到轶事证据的支持,只有少数方面经过实证检验。为了进一步探索这一领域,对一个方便的从业者样本(8 名医学专业人员和 6 名音乐家教练)进行了 14 次半结构式访谈,他们经常治疗 MFD 患者。在他们的职业生涯中,这些参与者估计与超过 2000 名患有 MFD 的音乐家进行了互动,形成了一个庞大的间接样本。数据中出现了一个详细的患者概况,有三个主要组成部分:1)社交环境的负面影响,包括创伤经历和乐器教学质量低;2)完美主义、焦虑、过度敏感和默许的人格类型;3)强迫性、控制性和不充分的练习行为。参与者表示,MFD 需要全面治疗,在治疗过程中忽视这些方面可能会危及康复。需要进一步进行客观、对照的研究试验,以详细描述这些因素,量化它们作为风险因素的潜在影响,并了解它们如何阻碍治疗。