Včelák J, Lesenský J, Špeldová A, Macko M
Ortopedická klinika 1. Lékařské fakulty Univerzity Karlovy a IPVZ, Fakultní nemocnice Na Bulovce, Praha.
Ortopedické oddělení, Klaudiánova nemocnice, Oblastní nemocnice Mladá Boleslav.
Acta Chir Orthop Traumatol Cech. 2022;89(4):300-308.
PURPOSE OF THE STUDY The retrospective study of patients treated for sacral chordoma with respect of complications, clinical outcomes and longterm survival is presented. Three main hypotheses have been formulated. Hypothesis 1: survival of patients with respect to generalization of the disease, manifestation of local recurrence and metastases with a R0 resection margin achieved is longer than survival of patients with a R1 or R2 resection margin. Hypothesis 2: survival of patients with the tumor resected from low endplate of S2 distally is longer than in tumors with resection above this level. Hypothesis 3: resection of large tumors with tumor volume greater than 800 cm³ is associated with a significantly shorter survival than resection of tumors with tumor volume less than 800 cm³. MATERIAL AND METHODS A total of 12 patients (7 women, 5 men), with the mean age of 54.3 years, underwent surgical treatment at our department in 1998-2018. Sacral chordoma proximally achieved S1 level in three cases, S2 level in four cases and S3 level in five cases with volume less than 800 cm³ in eight and greater in four patients. In nine patients sacrectomy using isolated posterior approach was performed and in three patients antero-posterior approach was applied. The Kaplan-Meier survival curve was calculated to estimate the survival of patients. The patients were divided into groups and subsequently compared with respect of achieved radicality of surgical resection, i.e. R0 vs. R1 or R2 resection, secondly of the proximal margin of the tumor/resection, i.e. S1 or S2 vs. S3 distally, and thirdly of the volume of the tumor, i.e. less than 800 cm³ vs. more than 800 cm³. RESULTS At the time of evaluation, a total of seven patients were alive (58.3%), with the mean survival of 9.5 years. One patient died from complications associated with the treatment of obstructive ileus manifested 10 months after primary surgery. The remaining four patients died in relation to the generalization of the disease 14.8 years after primary surgery on average. All the patients, in whom R0 resection was achieved, at the average time of evaluation of 7.3 years (range 2.8-15.8 years) showed no signs of local recurrence or generalization of the disease, whereas in group with R1, R2 resection at the time of evaluation only two patients were still alive, both 16.8 years on average (range 15.2-18.4 years) after surgery with repeatedly treated recurrencies. Frequent postoperative complications were observed in a total of five patients (41.7%). DISCUSSION The study did not confirm any difference in patient's survival with respect of the proximal margin affection of sacrum or tumor size. The decisive factor for survival of patients with sacral chordoma is achieving the R0 resection. The size of the chordoma and proximal achievement increase the complexity of surgery, manifestation of early perioperative and subsequently postoperative complications. CONCLUSIONS In primary surgical treatment of sacral chordoma, we always try to achieve R0 resection. In the case of low-volume tumors from S3 distally, we resect the tumor using the isolated posterior approach. The anterior-posterior approach is preferred in the case of large tumors presenting in the S1/2 region. Key words: sacral chordoma, sacral cancer, wide resection, sacrectomy, vertical rectus abdominus myocutaneous (VRAM) flap.
研究目的 本文对接受骶骨脊索瘤治疗的患者的并发症、临床结局和长期生存率进行回顾性研究。提出了三个主要假设。假设1:达到R0切除边缘的疾病全身转移、局部复发和转移患者的生存期长于R1或R2切除边缘的患者。假设2:从S2远端低终板切除肿瘤的患者的生存期长于肿瘤切除高于此水平的患者。假设3:肿瘤体积大于800 cm³的大肿瘤切除后的生存期明显短于肿瘤体积小于800 cm³的肿瘤切除后的生存期。材料与方法 1998年至2018年,共有12例患者(7例女性,5例男性),平均年龄54.3岁,在我科接受手术治疗。骶骨脊索瘤近端达到S1水平3例,S2水平4例,S3水平5例,8例患者肿瘤体积小于800 cm³,4例患者肿瘤体积大于800 cm³。9例患者采用单纯后路入路行骶骨切除术,3例患者采用前后联合入路。计算Kaplan-Meier生存曲线以评估患者的生存期。将患者分组,随后根据手术切除的根治程度(即R0与R1或R2切除)、肿瘤/切除近端边缘(即S1或S2与远端S3)以及肿瘤体积(即小于800 cm³与大于800 cm³)进行比较。结果 在评估时,共有7例患者存活(58.3%),平均生存期为9.5年。1例患者死于原发性手术后10个月出现的与肠梗阻治疗相关的并发症。其余4例患者平均在原发性手术后14.8年死于疾病全身转移。所有实现R0切除的患者,在平均评估时间7.3年(范围2.8 - 15.8年)时均未出现局部复发或疾病全身转移的迹象,而在R1、R2切除组,评估时仅2例患者仍存活,平均术后16.8年(范围15.2 - 18.4年),且复发多次接受治疗。总共5例患者(41.7%)观察到频繁的术后并发症。讨论 该研究未证实骶骨近端边缘受累或肿瘤大小对患者生存期有任何差异。骶骨脊索瘤患者生存的决定性因素是实现R0切除。脊索瘤的大小和近端范围增加了手术的复杂性、早期围手术期及随后术后并发症的表现。结论 在骶骨脊索瘤的一期手术治疗中,我们始终努力实现R0切除。对于S3远端小体积肿瘤,我们采用单纯后路入路切除肿瘤。对于S1/2区域的大肿瘤,优先采用前后联合入路。关键词:骶骨脊索瘤;骶骨癌;广泛切除;骶骨切除术;腹直肌肌皮瓣