Li Xiaodong
School of Foreign Studies, University of Science and Technology Beijing, Beijing, China.
Front Psychol. 2022 Aug 18;13:995660. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2022.995660. eCollection 2022.
Q methodology has been used in a variety of fields to employ a scientific approach to dealing with subjectivity; yet, its use has just gained momentum in the second language acquisition (SLA) domain recently (Damio, 2016). The present paper argues that Q methodology is remarkably efficient in representing the dynamic quality of complex systems involved in the language learning process, which is, thus, compatible with the complexity and dynamic systems theory (CDST). As Q methodology enjoys advantages of both qualitative and quantitative lines of research (Irie, 2014), it helps to explore and reflect L2 learners' subjective views and perceptions about their emotions in an L2 class in a comprehensive manner. With the current growing attention to individuals' emotional experiences in recent years, SLA research domain is ripe for many scientific inquiries about L2 learners' affective variables benefiting from this method. The few existing studies in the L2 domain have had interesting findings, which show the Q methodology should be more extensively used in the field to reveal facts about how learners feel in class from a within-individual point of view. Q methodology can hopefully be capable of representing the dynamicity and complexity of the affective variables language learners experience in the interactive network of classroom learning. Thus, it is expected that innovative research methods such as the Q methodology be employed significantly more than before in the dynamic phase of SLA research in the upcoming years.
Q 方法已在多个领域中使用,以采用科学方法来处理主观性;然而,它在第二语言习得(SLA)领域的应用直到最近才开始兴起(达米奥,2016)。本文认为,Q 方法在呈现语言学习过程中复杂系统的动态特性方面非常有效,因此与复杂性和动态系统理论(CDST)相契合。由于 Q 方法兼具定性和定量研究的优势(入江,2014),它有助于全面探索和反映二语学习者在二语课堂中对自身情感的主观观点和认知。近年来,随着对个体情感体验的关注度不断提高,二语习得研究领域已成熟到可以开展许多关于二语学习者情感变量的科学探究,而这种方法对此有益。二语领域中现有的少数研究已取得了有趣的发现,这些发现表明 Q 方法应在该领域更广泛地使用,以便从个体内部的角度揭示学习者在课堂上的感受。Q 方法有望能够呈现语言学习者在课堂学习互动网络中所经历的情感变量的动态性和复杂性。因此,预计在未来几年二语习得研究的动态阶段,诸如 Q 方法等创新研究方法的使用将比以往显著增加。