Liu Y R, Li Y P, Zhang W, Yang S Q, Ding J
Tianjin Eye Hospital, Nankai University Affiliated Eye Hospital, Clinical College of Ophthalmology of Tianjin Medical University, Tianjin Eye Institute, Tianjin Key Laboratory of Ophthalmology and Vision Science, Tianjin 300020, China.
Zhonghua Yan Ke Za Zhi. 2022 Sep 11;58(9):693-700. doi: 10.3760/cma.j.cn112142-20220124-00031.
To evaluate the efficacy and safety of superior rectus transposition (SRT) with/without augmented suture and vertical rectus transposition (VRT) for the treatment of strabismus caused by complete abducens nerve palsy. This was a retrospective cohort study. Forty-two patients (42 eyes) with complete abducens nerve palsy underwent strabismic surgeries from January 2015 to November 2020 in Tianjin Eye Hospital. According to the different procedures, the patients were divided into three groups: SRT group (16 cases, SRT with medial rectus recession), superior rectus transposition with augmented suture (SRTA) group (13 cases, SRT with Buckley suture and medial rectus recession) and VRT group (13 cases). The preoperative and postoperative (1, 6 and 12 months) data including deviations, ocular motility, binocular vision and surgical complications among three groups were analyzed and compared. χ test was used for comparison of count data among three groups. The measurement data were compared among three groups by the repeated measures ANOVA. LSD- test was used for within-group comparison and between-group comparison. There was no difference in sex ratio, age and course of disease among the groups (all >0.05). The horizontal deviations of the three groups at 1, 6 and 12 months after surgeries was lower than that before surgeries, and the difference was statistically significant (all <0.001). The horizontal deviations of the SRT group, SRTA group and VRT group at 12 months after surgeries were (+0.8±5.8), (+0.8±4.5), (+1.2±2.5) prism diopters (PD), respectively, lower than that of the preoperative (+82.8±17.2), (+77.7±26.1), (+71.5±18.6) PD. However, there was no significant difference among different postoperative follow-up timepoints (all >0.05). There was no difference in horizontal deviations before surgeries and at 1, 6 and 12 months after surgeries among three groups (>0.05). There were significant differences in the scales of abduction motility among preoperative, postoperative 1, 6 and 12 months measurements for three group (all <0.001). The scales of abduction before surgeries in the SRT group, SRTA group, and VRT group were (-4.4±0.5), (-4.4±0.5), (-4.5±0.5) scale and at 12 months after surgeries were (-2.3±0.7), (-2.2±0.5), (-2.1±0.6) scale respectively. But there was no change among different postoperative follow-up timepoints (all >0.05). Preoperative and postoperative 1-, 6-and 12-month abduction motility was similar among three groups (>0.05). There were significant differences in the scales of adduction limitation among preoperative, postoperative 1-, 6-and 12-months measurements for three group (all <0.05). But there was no change among different postoperative follow-up timepoints (all >0.05). There were significant differences between the SRT group [(-0.9±0.6), (-0.8±0.6) scale] and the SRTA groups [(-1.5±0.5), (-1.4±0.5) scale] (=-2.62, -2.52) and between the SRTA group and the VRT group [(-0.8±0.8), (-0.6±0.7) scale] (=2.62, 3.01) at 6 and 12 months after surgeries (all <0.05). The outcomes of binocular vision at postoperative 12 months were similar among three groups (>0.05). No patient had torsional diplopia and anterior segment ischemia. Only 2 patients from the SRTA group had hypotropia of 4 to 5 PD in the primary position associated with supraduction limitation. SRT with/without augmented suture and VRT are effective and safe procedures for the treatment of strabismus caused by complete abducens nerve palsy. They could correct deviations, improve abduction motility and restore binocular vision, with stable outcomes and a small risk of vertical and torsional diplopia.
评估上直肌转位术(SRT)联合或不联合增强缝线以及垂直直肌转位术(VRT)治疗完全性展神经麻痹所致斜视的疗效和安全性。这是一项回顾性队列研究。2015年1月至2020年11月期间,42例(42眼)完全性展神经麻痹患者在天津眼科医院接受了斜视手术。根据不同手术方式,将患者分为三组:SRT组(16例,上直肌转位联合内直肌后徙)、上直肌转位联合增强缝线(SRTA)组(13例,上直肌转位联合巴克利缝线及内直肌后徙)和VRT组(13例)。分析比较三组术前及术后(1、6和12个月)的斜视度、眼球运动、双眼视功能及手术并发症等数据。三组计数资料比较采用χ检验。三组计量资料比较采用重复测量方差分析。组内比较及组间比较采用LSD检验。各组间性别比、年龄及病程差异均无统计学意义(均>0.05)。三组术后1、6和12个月的水平斜视度均低于术前,差异有统计学意义(均<0.001)。术后12个月时,SRT组、SRTA组和VRT组的水平斜视度分别为(+0.8±5.8)、(+0.8±4.5)、(+1.2±2.5)棱镜度(PD),低于术前的(+82.8±17.2)、(+77.7±26.1)、(+71.5±18.6)PD。然而,不同术后随访时间点之间差异无统计学意义(均>0.05)。三组术前及术后1、6和12个月的水平斜视度差异无统计学意义(>0.05)。三组术前、术后1、6和12个月外展运动幅度差异有统计学意义(均<0.001)。SRT组、SRTA组和VRT组术前外展运动幅度分别为(-4.4±0.5)、(-4.4±0.5)、(-4.5±),术后12个月分别为(-2.3±0.7)、(-2.2±0.5)、(-2.1±0.6)。但不同术后随访时间点之间无变化(均>0.05)。三组术前及术后1、6和12个月的外展运动相似(>0.05)。三组术前、术后1、6和12个月内收受限幅度差异有统计学意义(均<0.05)。但不同术后随访时间点之间无变化(均>0.05)。术后6和12个月时,SRT组[(-0.9±0.6)、(-0.8±0.6)]与SRTA组[(-1.5±0.5)、(-1.4±)]之间差异有统计学意义(=-2.62,-2.52),SRTA组与VRT组[(-0.8±0.8)、(-0.6±0.7)]之间差异有统计学意义(=2.62,3.01)(均<0.05)。术后12个月时三组双眼视功能结果相似(>0.05)。无患者出现旋转性复视和眼前节缺血。仅SRTA组有2例患者在第一眼位有4~5 PD的下斜视并伴有上转受限。上直肌转位联合或不联合增强缝线以及垂直直肌转位术是治疗完全性展神经麻痹所致斜视的有效且安全的手术方法。它们可矫正斜视度、改善外展运动并恢复双眼视功能,疗效稳定,垂直和旋转性复视风险小。