Yang Dong, Chen Peng, Wang Huanhuan, Wang Kai, Huang Ronghuai
Smart Learning Institute, Beijing Normal University, Beijing, China.
College of Education, Capital Normal University, Beijing, China.
Front Psychol. 2022 Aug 22;13:925955. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2022.925955. eCollection 2022.
Autonomy support is one of the most crucial determinants of teaching practice for student engagement. No literature review on the relations between autonomy support and student engagement existed to the best of our knowledge. Therefore, this study presents a systematic literature review from perspectives of landscapes, methodology characters, patterns of identified studies, and autonomy-supportive strategies. Overall, 31 articles were reviewed. Followed by PRISMA guidelines, the results yielded several interesting facts: First, studies on such topics surged starting from 2015 and were mostly conducted in the United States (32%) and Korea (16%). Publications were scattered but heavily gathered around psychological and educational journals such as the (9.7%). Most often, studies recruited participants from upper secondary schools (58%). Data were collected using solely questionnaires (93.5%) following a two-wave design (51.6%) and were analyzed by applying structural equation models (48.4%). Moreover, most of the studies failed to provide concrete autonomy-supportive teaching strategies. Instead, quite often studies (93%) investigated its relations with student engagement from a macro perspective. Within mentioned strategies, they were mostly related to the teaching process, there is a limited investigation of autonomy-supportive teaching practice used before and after instruction. This pattern of results suggested an urgent need for more longitudinal studies on specific teaching strategies that hold the potential to maximize student engagement. Limitations and suggestions for future studies were provided accordingly.
自主支持是影响学生参与度的教学实践的最关键决定因素之一。据我们所知,目前尚无关于自主支持与学生参与度之间关系的文献综述。因此,本研究从研究概况、方法特点、已识别研究的模式以及自主支持策略等方面进行了系统的文献综述。总体而言,共审查了31篇文章。按照PRISMA指南,研究结果得出了几个有趣的事实:首先,关于此类主题的研究从2015年开始激增,大部分研究在美国(32%)和韩国(16%)进行。出版物分布零散,但大量集中在《》等心理和教育期刊周围(9.7%)。大多数情况下,研究招募的参与者来自高中(58%)。数据仅通过问卷收集(93.5%),采用两波设计(51.6%),并通过应用结构方程模型进行分析(48.4%)。此外,大多数研究未能提供具体的自主支持教学策略。相反,研究常常(93%)从宏观角度调查其与学生参与度的关系。在提及的策略中,它们大多与教学过程相关,对教学前后使用的自主支持教学实践的研究有限。这种结果模式表明,迫切需要对有可能最大限度提高学生参与度的具体教学策略进行更多的纵向研究。相应地提供了研究的局限性和对未来研究的建议。