Imperial College School of Medicine, Imperial College London, London, United Kingdom.
Department of Otolaryngology, Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust, London, United Kingdom.
Laryngoscope. 2023 Jul;133(7):1606-1613. doi: 10.1002/lary.30364. Epub 2022 Sep 8.
The COVID-19 pandemic has caused unprecedented disruptions to medical education. Education in medical specialties, such as otolaryngology faces multiple challenges, including reduced bedside and "hands-on" training opportunities at all levels. Educators are turning to technological advancements to deliver effective remote medical education. This study investigated the value of enhancing traditional remote case-based teaching with the HoloLens2™.
We present a randomized educational design study. All educational content, media, and learning outcomes were identical. Primary outcome measures included student performance as measured with pre- and post-intervention quizzes and student engagement as measured by a tally-mark system. Secondary outcome measures, collected using feedback questionnaires, included perceived enjoyment, engagement, and opinions regarding the educational role of this technology.
The undergraduate medical students were randomized to either conventional or HoloLens2™ enhanced remote case-based teaching (n = 56). HoloLens2™ enhanced teaching improved student performance by an average of 3 marks of 15% (p < 0.001). It was engaging and encouraged questions 4-fold per session (p < 0.05) when compared to conventional remote case-based teaching. There was no significant difference in overall objective measurements of engagement. Students taught using HoloLens2™ agreed that the teaching was enjoyable, effective in concept demonstration, and encouraged engagement.
Remote teaching has allowed for the continuation of medical education in uncertain times. Beyond COVID-19, we predict that there will be a paradigm shift toward remote learning as new technological advancements emerges. These novel technologies may prove invaluable in the future potentially enabling education to be delivered between different hospitals, universities, and even overseas.
NA Laryngoscope, 133:1606-1613, 2023.
COVID-19 大流行对医学教育造成了前所未有的破坏。耳鼻喉等医学专业的教育面临着多种挑战,包括各级减少床边和“实践”培训机会。教育工作者正在转向技术进步来提供有效的远程医学教育。本研究调查了使用 HoloLens2™增强传统远程基于案例的教学的价值。
我们进行了一项随机教育设计研究。所有教育内容、媒体和学习成果都是相同的。主要结果测量包括通过干预前后测验测量的学生表现和通过标记系统测量的学生参与度。使用反馈问卷收集的次要结果包括感知的乐趣、参与度以及对该技术教育作用的看法。
将医学生随机分为常规或 HoloLens2™增强远程基于案例的教学组(n=56)。HoloLens2™增强教学使学生的平均成绩提高了 3 分,提高了 15%(p<0.001)。与传统远程基于案例的教学相比,它更具吸引力,并鼓励每个课程提出 4 倍的问题(p<0.05)。总体参与度的客观测量没有显著差异。使用 HoloLens2™进行教学的学生认为教学有趣、概念演示有效,并鼓励参与。
远程教学使医学教育能够在不确定时期继续进行。除 COVID-19 之外,我们预计随着新的技术进步出现,远程学习将出现范式转变。这些新技术在未来可能具有巨大价值,有可能使教育能够在不同的医院、大学甚至海外进行。
无 Laryngoscope, 133:1606-1613, 2023.