Haid Bernhard, Tack Lloyd J W, Spinoit Anne-Françoise, Weigl Chiara, Steinkellner Lukas, Gernhold Christa, Banuelos Beatriz, Sforza Simone, O'Kelly Fardod, Oswald Josef
Department of Paediatric Urology, Ordensklinikum Linz Hospital of the Sisters of Charity, Linz, Austria.
Department of Internal Medicine and Paediatrics, Division of Paediatric Endocrinology, Ghent University Hospital, Ghent University, Ghent, Belgium.
J Pediatr Urol. 2022 Oct;18(5):609.e1-609.e11. doi: 10.1016/j.jpurol.2022.08.014. Epub 2022 Aug 23.
Being born small for gestational age (SGA) is associated with a higher frequency and more severe forms of hypospadias as well as with potential developmental differences. This study aims to characterize operative outcomes in SGA boys compared to boys born with normal weight and length for gestational age (appropriate/large for gestational age, AGA/LGA).
Demographic data, hypospadias characteristics, associated pathologies and operative outcomes of boys who underwent hypospadias repair at a single center (10/2012-10/2019) were evaluated. Boys were categorized into SGA and non-SGA, which were then compared using unpaired t-tests and chi square tests. To examine the effect of SGA on reoperative risk, a logistic regression model was applied integrating surgical technique, meatal localization and complex hypospadias (narrow glans/plate, curvature, micropenis, bilateral cryptorchidism).
SGA boys accounted for 13.7% (n = 80) of the total cohort (n = 584) and 33% of all proximal hypospadias (n = 99, SGA vs. non-SGA 41.3% vs. 13%, p < 0.001). After a mean follow-up of 18.6 months the reoperation rate for all hypospadias was 17.9% (n = 105). In distal hypospadias there was no difference in reoperation rate between SGA and AGA/LGA boys (p = 0.548, multivariate regression model). For each meatal localization in proximal hypospadias SGA was a significant, independent factor predicting higher reoperation rates (p = 0.019, OR 3.21) in a logistic regression model (Figure ROC).
Hypospadias surgery carries a substantial risk for unplanned reinterventions. Apart from meatal localization, there are only a few factors (urethral plate quality, glandular diameter, curvature) reported in literature to be associated with reoperative risk. Intrauterine growth retardation associated with SGA might lead to not only a higher probability of proximal hypospadias but also contribute to a higher risk for complications mediated by developmental differences. Whether these findings could help to tailor surgical strategies or adjuvant measures, as for example the application of preoperative hormonal stimulation remains to be determined in future studies. This study is limited by being a single-center series with limited follow-up resulting in some complications probably not yet detected - however, in the same extent in both groups.
Based on this study, 33% of all proximal hypospadias cases occur in boys born SGA. While the reoperation rate in boys with distal hypospadias was not influenced by SGA status, SGA proved to be an independent predictor of a higher risk of reoperation in those with proximal hypospadias. After validation of these findings in other centers, this could be integrated into counseling and risk-stratification.
小于胎龄儿(SGA)出生时尿道下裂的发生率更高、病情更严重,且可能存在潜在的发育差异。本研究旨在比较SGA男童与出生体重和身长符合胎龄(适于胎龄/大于胎龄,AGA/LGA)男童的手术效果。
评估在单一中心(2012年10月至2019年10月)接受尿道下裂修复手术的男童的人口统计学数据、尿道下裂特征、相关病理情况及手术效果。将男童分为SGA组和非SGA组,然后采用非配对t检验和卡方检验进行比较。为研究SGA对再次手术风险的影响,应用逻辑回归模型,纳入手术技术、尿道口位置及复杂尿道下裂(阴茎头/尿道板狭窄、阴茎弯曲、小阴茎、双侧隐睾)等因素。
SGA男童占总队列(n = 584)的13.7%(n = 80),占所有近端尿道下裂病例(n = 99)的33%(SGA组与非SGA组分别为41.3%和13%,p < 0.001)。平均随访18.6个月后,所有尿道下裂的再次手术率为17.9%(n = 105)。在远端尿道下裂中,SGA男童与AGA/LGA男童的再次手术率无差异(p = 0.548,多变量回归模型)。在近端尿道下裂中,对于每个尿道口位置,SGA是预测再次手术率较高的一个显著独立因素(p = 0.019,OR 3.21),在逻辑回归模型中(图ROC)。
尿道下裂手术存在计划外再次干预的重大风险。除尿道口位置外,文献中报道的与再次手术风险相关的因素仅有少数几个(尿道板质量、阴茎头直径、阴茎弯曲)。与SGA相关的宫内生长迟缓可能不仅导致近端尿道下裂的发生率更高,还会增加由发育差异介导的并发症风险。这些发现是否有助于制定手术策略或辅助措施,例如术前激素刺激的应用,仍有待未来研究确定。本研究的局限性在于它是一个单中心系列研究,随访有限,导致一些并发症可能尚未被发现——然而,两组受影响程度相同。
基于本研究,所有近端尿道下裂病例中有33%发生在SGA出生的男童中。虽然远端尿道下裂男童的再次手术率不受SGA状态影响,但SGA被证明是近端尿道下裂男童再次手术风险较高的独立预测因素。在其他中心验证这些发现后,可将其纳入咨询和风险分层。