Centre of Social and Psychological Sciences, SAS, Bratislava, Slovakia.
Biopreserv Biobank. 2023 Aug;21(4):318-326. doi: 10.1089/bio.2022.0073. Epub 2022 Sep 13.
Biobanks that intend to serve as high-performing and stable elements of an innovative research ecosystem must have an established system for regular measurement and evaluation using appropriately set indicators. The main objective of this study was to provide a comprehensive overview of indicators in the context of biobanking, with new perspectives to highlight the existence of numerous options and introduce indicators that could help overcome problems associated with the difficult assessment of the impact of biobanks. A literature review was performed to identify publications relevant to the topic of indicators in biobanking. The Web of Science Core Collection and PubMed databases were searched using specific keywords. In addition, three articles that focused on indicators designed for the evaluation of research infrastructures were included in the review. Based on the scientific literature for the biobanking field, many types of quantitative and qualitative indicators exist. They are mainly related to the quantity and quality of data and samples, their distribution, the monitoring of research projects, and subsequent publication outputs. The indicators identified in the biobanking literature primarily focus on the outcome, not the impact. Indicators identified in the biobanking literature may be further expanded with suggestions designed for other types of research infrastructures, while considering the context where biobanks operate and the needs of individual biobanking stakeholders. The establishment of a comprehensive monitoring system that captures all necessary elements is crucial for modern biobanks.
生物银行若要成为创新研究生态系统中高性能和稳定的组成部分,就必须建立一个使用适当设定指标进行定期测量和评估的既定系统。本研究的主要目的是提供生物银行背景下指标的全面概述,提出新的观点来强调存在众多选择,并引入有助于克服与难以评估生物银行影响相关问题的指标。
进行了文献回顾,以确定与生物银行指标主题相关的出版物。使用特定关键字在 Web of Science 核心合集和 PubMed 数据库中进行了搜索。此外,还纳入了三篇专门针对研究基础设施评估设计的指标的文章。
基于生物银行领域的科学文献,存在许多类型的定量和定性指标。它们主要与数据和样本的数量和质量、它们的分布、研究项目的监测以及随后的出版物产出有关。生物银行文献中确定的指标主要侧重于结果,而不是影响。
生物银行文献中确定的指标可以通过针对其他类型的研究基础设施提出的建议进一步扩展,同时考虑到生物银行运作的背景和各个生物银行利益相关者的需求。建立一个全面的监测系统,捕捉所有必要的要素,对于现代生物银行至关重要。