Karmanos Cancer Center/Wayne State University, Detroit, Michigan, USA.
Vanderbilt University Medical Center, Nashville, Tennessee, USA.
J Appl Clin Med Phys. 2022 Oct;23(10):e13771. doi: 10.1002/acm2.13771. Epub 2022 Sep 15.
The Professional Doctorate in Medical Physics (DMP) was originally conceived as a solution to the shortage of medical physics residency training positions. While this shortage has now been largely satisfied through conventional residency training positions, the DMP has expanded to multiple institutions and grown into an educational pathway that provides specialized clinical training and extends well beyond the creation of additional training spots. As such, it is important to reevaluate the purpose and the value of the DMP. Additionally, it is important to outline the defining characteristics of the DMP to assure that all existing and future programs provide this anticipated value. Since the formation and subsequent accreditation of the first DMP program in 2009-2010, four additional programs have been created and accredited. However, no guidelines have yet been recommended by the American Association of Physicists in Medicine. CAMPEP accreditation of these programs has thus far been based only on the respective graduate and residency program standards. This allows the development and operation of DMP programs which contain only the requisite Master of Science (MS) coursework and a 2-year clinical training program. Since the MS plus 2-year residency pathway already exists, this form of DMP does not provide added value, and one may question why this existing pathway should be considered a doctorate. Not only do we, as a profession, need to outline the defining characteristics of the DMP, we need to carefully evaluate the potential advantages and disadvantages of this pathway within our education and training infrastructure. The aims of this report from the Working Group on the Professional Doctorate Degree for Medical Physicists (WGPDMP) are to (1) describe the current state of the DMP within the profession, (2) make recommendations on the structure and content of the DMP for existing and new DMP programs, and (3) evaluate the value of the DMP to the profession of medical physics.
医学物理学专业博士(DMP)最初是作为解决医学物理学住院医师培训职位短缺的一种解决方案而设想的。虽然这种短缺现在已经通过传统的住院医师培训职位得到了很大程度的满足,但 DMP 已经扩展到多个机构,并发展成为一种提供专业临床培训的教育途径,其范围远远超出了增加培训岗位的范围。因此,重新评估 DMP 的目的和价值非常重要。此外,概述 DMP 的定义特征也很重要,以确保所有现有的和未来的项目都能提供预期的价值。自 2009-2010 年第一个 DMP 项目成立并随后获得认证以来,又创建并认证了四个项目。然而,美国医学物理学家协会尚未推荐任何指导方针。这些项目的 CAMPEP 认证迄今为止仅基于各自的研究生和住院医师项目标准。这使得 DMP 项目的开发和运营只包含必要的理学硕士(MS)课程和为期 2 年的临床培训项目。由于 MS 加 2 年住院医师途径已经存在,这种形式的 DMP 并没有增加价值,人们可能会质疑为什么这种现有的途径应该被视为博士学位。我们作为一个专业,不仅需要概述 DMP 的定义特征,还需要仔细评估这种途径在我们的教育和培训基础设施中的潜在优势和劣势。医学物理学家专业博士学位工作组(WGPDMP)的这份报告旨在:(1)描述 DMP 在专业领域的现状;(2)为现有和新的 DMP 项目提出 DMP 的结构和内容建议;(3)评估 DMP 对医学物理学专业的价值。