Rubens R D, Begent R H, Knight R K, Sexton S A, Hayward J L
Cancer. 1978 Oct;42(4):1680-6. doi: 10.1002/1097-0142(197810)42:4<1680::aid-cncr2820420404>3.0.co;2-a.
Sixty-nine patients with advanced breast cancer treated with cytotoxic chemotherapy were randomized to receive concomitantly either norethisterone acetate (progestogen group) or a placebo (placebo group). Objective responses were seen in 53% of patients in the progestogen group and 61% of patients in the placebo group. The median duration of response was the same for both groups (38 weeks). Three out of ten patients in the placebo group, who received subsequently the progestogen on relapse, had a further objective regression. The overall survival in the two groups was similar, although in a sub-group of patients who had operable tumors, but a subsequent short disease-free interval, survival was significantly better in the placebo group. There was less myelosuppression in the progestogen group, who were able to receive higher doses of cytotoxic drugs. Less nausea and vomiting occurred in the progestogen group, but subjective side effects were similar. It is concluded that there is no advantage therapeutically in combining cytotoxic chemotherapy and progestogen therapy and, in some patients, better results are obtained using the two treatments sequentially.
69例接受细胞毒性化疗的晚期乳腺癌患者被随机分组,分别同时接受醋酸炔诺酮治疗(孕激素组)或安慰剂治疗(安慰剂组)。孕激素组53%的患者和安慰剂组61%的患者出现客观缓解。两组的中位缓解持续时间相同(38周)。安慰剂组中有10名患者在复发后接受了孕激素治疗,其中3名患者出现了进一步的客观缓解。两组的总生存率相似,不过在一组肿瘤可切除但随后无病间期较短的患者亚组中,安慰剂组的生存率显著更高。孕激素组的骨髓抑制较轻,因此能够接受更高剂量的细胞毒性药物。孕激素组的恶心和呕吐较少,但主观副作用相似。研究得出结论,细胞毒性化疗与孕激素治疗联合使用在治疗上并无优势,在某些患者中,序贯使用这两种治疗方法可获得更好的效果。