Hsu Yu-Jen, Chern Yih-Jong, Lai I-Li, Chiang Sum-Fu, Liao Chun-Kai, Tsai Wen-Sy, Hung Hsin-Yuan, Hsieh Pao-Shiu, Yeh Chien-Yuh, Chiang Jy-Ming, Yu Yen-Lin, You Jeng-Fu
Division of Colon and Rectal Surgery, Chang Gung Memorial Hospital, Chang Gung University College of Medicine, Guei-Shan, Tao-Yuan, Taiwan.
School of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Chang Gung University, Graduate Institute of Clinical Medical Sciences, Chang Gung University, Tao-Yuan, Taiwan.
Open Med (Wars). 2022 Sep 5;17(1):1438-1448. doi: 10.1515/med-2022-0555. eCollection 2022.
It is controversial whether patients who achieve clinical complete remission (cCR) of rectal cancer should be treated with the "watch and wait" (W&W) or radical resection (RR) strategy. Our study aimed to compare the survival outcomes and ostomy rate of the W&W and RR strategies. Between January 2008 and December 2015, we investigated 26 patients who achieved pathologic complete remission after undergoing RR and 36 patients who adopted the W&W strategy because of cCR. The tumor regrowth, salvage surgery, recurrence, disease-free, and overall survival (OS) rates were assessed. In our study, recurrences occurred in nine and two patients from the W&W and RR groups, respectively. Each patient in the RR group had a temporary or permanent ostomy, but only three (8.3%) had an ostomy in the W&W group. The 5-year recurrence rate was 25.0% in the W&W group and 7.7% in the RR group. Six patients (16.7%) had tumor regrowth in the W&W group, and all were resectable when regrowth. The 5-year OS rates between the two groups were nonsignificant. There is no specific risk factor for recurrence and OS. Under close surveillance, the W&W group achieved similar OS to the RR group and benefited from a lower ostomy rate.
直肠癌临床完全缓解(cCR)的患者应采用“观察等待”(W&W)还是根治性切除(RR)策略存在争议。我们的研究旨在比较W&W和RR策略的生存结局和造口率。在2008年1月至2015年12月期间,我们调查了26例接受RR后实现病理完全缓解的患者以及36例因cCR而采用W&W策略的患者。评估了肿瘤再生长、挽救性手术、复发、无病生存率和总生存率(OS)。在我们的研究中,W&W组和RR组分别有9例和2例患者出现复发。RR组的每位患者都有临时或永久性造口,但W&W组只有3例(8.3%)有造口。W&W组的5年复发率为25.0%,RR组为7.7%。W&W组有6例患者(16.7%)出现肿瘤再生长,再生长时均可切除。两组之间的5年OS率无显著差异。复发和OS没有特定的危险因素。在密切监测下,W&W组的OS与RR组相似,且受益于较低的造口率。