Institute of Reproductive and Child Health / National Health Commission Key Laboratory of Reproductive Health and Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, School of Public Health, Peking University Health Science Centre, Beijing, China.
College of Environmental Sciences and Engineering, Peking University, Beijing, China.
Environ Int. 2022 Nov;169:107520. doi: 10.1016/j.envint.2022.107520. Epub 2022 Sep 13.
The U-shaped association between health outcomes and ambient temperatures has been extensively investigated. However, such analyses cannot fully estimate the mortality burden of climate change because the features of the association (e.g., minimum mortality temperature) vary with human adaptation; thus, they are not generalizable to different locations. In this study, we assumed that humans could adapt to regular temperature variations; and thus examined the all-cause mortality attributable to temperature anomaly (TA), an indicator widely utilized in climate science to measure irregular temperature fluctuations, across 115 cities in the United States (US). We first used quasi-Poisson regressions to obtain the city-specific TA-mortality associations, then used meta-regression to pool these city-specific estimates. Finally, we calculated the number of TA-related deaths using the uniform pooled association, then compared it to the estimates from city-specific associations, which had been controlled for adaptation. Meta-regression showed a U-shaped TA-mortality association, centered at a TA near 0. According to the pooled association, 0.579 % (95 % confidence interval [CI]: 0.465-0.681 %), 0.394 % (95 % CI: 0.332-0.451 %), and 0.185 % (95 % CI: 0.107-0.254 %) of all-cause deaths were attributable to all anomalous temperatures (TA ≠ 0), anomalous heat (TA > 0), and anomalous cold (TA < 0), respectively. At the city level, heat-related deaths estimated from the pooled association were in good agreement with heat-related deaths estimated from the city-specific associations (R = 0.84). However, the cold-related deaths estimated from the two methods showed a weaker correlation (R = 0.07). Our findings suggest that TA constitutes a generalizable indicator that can uniformly evaluate deaths attributable to anomalous heat in distinct geographical locations.
健康结果与环境温度之间的 U 型关联已被广泛研究。然而,此类分析无法完全估计气候变化的死亡负担,因为关联的特征(例如,最低死亡率温度)会随着人类适应而变化;因此,它们不适用于不同的地点。在这项研究中,我们假设人类可以适应常规的温度变化;因此,我们研究了 115 个美国城市归因于温度异常(TA)的全因死亡率,TA 是气候科学中广泛用于衡量不规则温度波动的指标。我们首先使用拟泊松回归获得特定城市的 TA-死亡率关联,然后使用荟萃回归汇总这些特定城市的估计值。最后,我们使用均匀汇总关联计算与 TA 相关的死亡人数,然后将其与经过适应控制的特定城市关联的估计值进行比较。荟萃回归显示 TA-死亡率呈 U 型关联,中心在接近 0 的 TA 处。根据汇总关联,0.579%(95%置信区间[CI]:0.465-0.681%)、0.394%(95%CI:0.332-0.451%)和 0.185%(95%CI:0.107-0.254%)的全因死亡归因于所有异常温度(TA≠0)、异常热(TA>0)和异常冷(TA<0)。在城市层面,从汇总关联中估计的与热相关的死亡与从特定城市关联中估计的与热相关的死亡一致(R=0.84)。然而,从两种方法估计的与冷相关的死亡相关性较弱(R=0.07)。我们的研究结果表明,TA 是一个可推广的指标,可以统一评估不同地理位置归因于异常热的死亡人数。