Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, University of California, Davis, United States.
Department of Computer Sciences, University of California, Davis, United States.
Neuroimage Clin. 2022;36:103214. doi: 10.1016/j.nicl.2022.103214. Epub 2022 Sep 29.
Although deep learning holds great promise as a prognostic tool in psychiatry, a limitation of the method is that it requires large training sample sizes to achieve replicable accuracy. This is problematic for fMRI datasets as they are typically small due to the considerable time, cost, and resources necessary to obtain them. A recently developed self-supervised learning method called Mixup may help overcome this challenge. In Mixup, the learner combines pairs of training instances to produce a virtual third instance that is a linear combination of the two instances and their labels. This procedure is also well-suited to the coregistered images typically found in fMRI datasets. Here we compared performance of a task fMRI-based deep learner with Mixup vs without Mixup on predicting response to treatment in recent onset psychosis. Whole brain fMRI time series data were extracted from a cognitive control task in 82 patients with recent onset psychosis and used to predict "Improver" (n = 47) vs "Non-Improver" (n = 35) status, with Improver defined as showing a 20 % reduction in total Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale score after 1 year of treatment. Mixup significantly improved performance (accuracy without Mixup: 76.5 % [95 % CI: 75.9-77.1 %]; accuracy with Mixup: 80.1 % [95 % CI: 79.4-80.8 %]). Ablation showed the improvement was due to improvement in both Improvers and Non-Improvers. These results suggest that using Mixup may significantly improve performance and reduce overfitting of fMRI-based prognostic deep learners and may also help overcome the small sample size challenge inherent to many neuroimaging datasets.
虽然深度学习作为精神病学的预后工具具有很大的前景,但该方法的一个限制是它需要大量的训练样本才能达到可重复的准确性。这对于 fMRI 数据集来说是一个问题,因为它们通常由于获得它们所需的大量时间、成本和资源而较小。最近开发的一种称为 Mixup 的自监督学习方法可能有助于克服这一挑战。在 Mixup 中,学习者将一对训练实例进行组合,以生成一个虚拟的第三个实例,该实例是两个实例及其标签的线性组合。该过程也非常适合 fMRI 数据集中通常发现的配准图像。在这里,我们比较了基于 fMRI 的深度学习器与 Mixup 和不使用 Mixup 对近期精神病发作患者的治疗反应进行预测的性能。从 82 名近期精神病发作患者的认知控制任务中提取全脑 fMRI 时间序列数据,并用于预测“改善者”(n=47)与“非改善者”(n=35)的状态,改善者定义为在治疗 1 年后总简明精神病评定量表评分降低 20%。Mixup 显著提高了性能(不使用 Mixup 的准确性:76.5%[95%CI:75.9-77.1%];使用 Mixup 的准确性:80.1%[95%CI:79.4-80.8%])。消融显示,改进是由于改善者和非改善者的改善。这些结果表明,使用 Mixup 可能会显著提高 fMRI 预后深度学习器的性能并减少过拟合,并且还可能有助于克服许多神经影像学数据集固有的小样本量挑战。