Ramos-Lara María de la Paz, Carreón-Vázquez Gustavo, Acatitla-Romero Edgar, Mendoza-Rosas Rosa María
Center for Interdisciplinary Research in Sciences and Humanities, National Autonomous University of Mexico, Mexico City, Mexico.
Institute of Economic Research, National Autonomous University of Mexico, Mexico City, Mexico.
Found Sci. 2022 Sep 28:1-28. doi: 10.1007/s10699-022-09872-y.
This paper employs network theory, mining data and bibliometric analysis when mapping the scientific contribution of Nobel Prize candidate; Manuel Sandoval Vallarta, the first and most renowned Mexican physicist and important figure in Latin American science. Vallarta died in 1977, and the existing literature is about his life and contributions to science but not about how those are still valuable today. This paper is the first to highlight, with mapping tools, that his contributions are relevant to the international community of cosmic rays (as he was pioneer and leader), quantum mechanics and relativity. These tools delivered three findings: Identify how he built his own field of study, same as universal knowledge. Unveil that the backward and forward Vallarta citations follow a network distribution. Determine social factors that benefited or affected his scientific activities-such as World War II interrupting Vallarta's successful productivity at Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Furthermore, this study confirmed the interdisciplinary nature of the mapping studies of the scientist's contributions using scientometric tools. As a result, several interesting questions arose throughout our research, some of which were answered from the history and philosophy of science. However, others need to be analyzed by experts in the fields of Vallarta. Mapping research sends an invitation to interdisciplinary dialogue/research between experts in different areas of study to better understand the process of knowledge production both, individual and collective.
本文在描绘诺贝尔奖候选人曼努埃尔·桑多瓦尔·巴利亚尔塔(Manuel Sandoval Vallarta)的科学贡献时,运用了网络理论、挖掘数据和文献计量分析方法。巴利亚尔塔是第一位也是最著名的墨西哥物理学家,是拉丁美洲科学界的重要人物。他于1977年去世,现有文献多是关于他的生平以及他对科学的贡献,而非这些贡献在当今如何依然具有价值。本文首次借助绘图工具强调,他的贡献与国际宇宙射线学界(因为他是先驱和领导者)、量子力学和相对论相关。这些工具得出了三个发现:确定他如何构建自己的研究领域,如同构建普遍知识一样。揭示巴利亚尔塔的前后向引文遵循网络分布。确定有利于或影响其科学活动的社会因素——比如第二次世界大战中断了巴利亚尔塔在麻省理工学院的高产期。此外,本研究证实了运用科学计量工具绘制科学家贡献图谱研究的跨学科性质。结果,在我们的研究过程中出现了几个有趣的问题,其中一些问题从科学史和科学哲学角度得到了回答。然而,其他问题需要巴利亚尔塔相关领域的专家进行分析。图谱研究呼吁不同研究领域的专家进行跨学科对话/研究,以便更好地理解个体和集体知识生产的过程。