Chotto Jensen, Lozy Erica D, Marin Rachel, Donaldson Jeanne M
Department of Psychology, Louisiana State University.
J Appl Behav Anal. 2023 Jan;56(1):131-145. doi: 10.1002/jaba.955. Epub 2022 Oct 5.
Due to the prevalence of words that cannot be read phonetically in the English language, sight word instruction is required to supplement phonics instruction. In this study, we manipulated stimulus disparity in sight word sets by comparing the effects of sets of sight words with the same initial letter (3 words per set, 3 total sets) versus distributing words with the same initial letter across sets when assessing acquisition of the combined set (9 words) for 5 children who ranged from 4-6 years of age using a combined adapted alternating treatments design and pre-posttest design. All participants mastered the 3-word sets in both teaching conditions but did not master the control sets. In general, participants required more teaching sessions when the words in sets began with the same letter. These findings are consistent with stimulus disparity research demonstrating that discrimination training is generally less efficient when comparison stimuli are similar.
由于英语中存在大量无法通过语音拼读的单词,因此需要进行视觉词教学来补充自然拼读教学。在本研究中,我们通过比较具有相同首字母的视觉词集(每组3个单词,共3组)与在评估5名4至6岁儿童对组合集(9个单词)的习得情况时将具有相同首字母的单词分散在不同组的效果,来操纵视觉词集中的刺激差异,采用了组合适应性交替治疗设计和前测-后测设计。所有参与者在两种教学条件下都掌握了3个单词的组,但没有掌握对照组的单词。总体而言,当组中的单词以相同字母开头时,参与者需要更多的教学课程。这些发现与刺激差异研究一致,表明当比较刺激相似时,辨别训练通常效率较低。