Gu Min Jae, Yi Jae Hyuck, Kim Young Hwan, Lee Hee Jung, Kang Ung Rae, Ji Seung Woo
Taehan Yongsang Uihakhoe Chi. 2020 Jan;81(1):166-175. doi: 10.3348/jksr.2020.81.1.166. Epub 2020 Jan 31.
This study aimed to compare the image quality and adverse events between Iopamidol 250 and Ioversol 320 usage during transcatheter arterial chemoembolization (TACE) for hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC).
Medical records and hepatic angiography from 113 patients who underwent TACE with Iopamidol 250 (44 patients) and Ioversol 320 (69 patients) were retrospectively reviewed. Vessel perception on hepatic angiography was graded into three categories by two radiologists for hepatic subsegmental arteries, the right gastroepiploic artery, right gastric artery, and pancreaticoduodenal artery. Imaging concordance was assessed by comparing the number of detected HCCs on hepatic angiography and CT. The adverse events before and after hepatic angiography were evaluated.
The mean vessel perception scores were 2.92 and 2.94 for Iopamidol 250 and Ioversol 320, respectively. The imaging concordance was 31 (70.5%) and 46 (66.7%) patients for Iopamidol 250 and Ioversol 320, respectively. There were no statistical differences in vessel perception or imaging concordance ( > 0.05). One and six patients experienced nausea for Iopamidol 250 and Ioversol 320, respectively. There was no statistical difference in adverse events ( = 0.24).
Iopamidol 250 can be used in hepatic angiography for TACE without significant difference in image quality or occurrence of adverse events from Ioversol 320.
本研究旨在比较在肝细胞癌(HCC)经动脉化疗栓塞术(TACE)中使用碘帕醇250和碘克沙醇320时的图像质量和不良事件。
回顾性分析113例行TACE的患者的病历和肝血管造影资料,其中44例使用碘帕醇250,69例使用碘克沙醇320。两名放射科医生将肝血管造影中肝段下动脉、胃网膜右动脉、胃右动脉和胰十二指肠动脉的血管显影分为三类。通过比较肝血管造影和CT上检测到的HCC数量来评估影像一致性。评估肝血管造影前后的不良事件。
碘帕醇250和碘克沙醇320的平均血管显影评分分别为2.92和2.94。碘帕醇250和碘克沙醇320的影像一致性分别为31例(70.5%)和46例(66.7%)患者。血管显影或影像一致性方面无统计学差异(>0.05)。碘帕醇250和碘克沙醇320分别有1例和6例患者出现恶心。不良事件方面无统计学差异(=0.24)。
碘帕醇250可用于TACE的肝血管造影,其图像质量或不良事件发生率与碘克沙醇320无显著差异。