Kalashnikova Olga, Leontiev Dmitry, Rasskazova Elena, Taranenko Olga
Crisis Department, Eramishantsev Moscow City Clinical Hospital, Moscow, Russia.
International Laboratory of Positive Psychology of Personality and Motivation, HSE University, Moscow, Russia.
Front Psychol. 2022 Sep 30;13:957782. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2022.957782. eCollection 2022.
Meaning is an important psychological resource both in situations of accomplishment and in situations of ongoing adversity and psychological crisis. Meaning in life underlies the reasons for staying alive both in everyday and in critical circumstances, fulfilling a buffering function with respect to life adversities.
The aim of the present study was to reveal the role of both meaningfulness, including specific sources of meaning and reasons for living, and meaninglessness (alienation) in patients suffering from profound crisis situations with or without suicidal intentions and behavior.
The sample included 148 patients (all Caucasian) who were referred to a crisis center in Moscow, Russia. Seventy-seven patients (54 females, mean age 32.00 ± 11.98 years) reported a current crisis situation in their life but denied suicidal thoughts or behavior. Twenty-nine patients (21 females, mean age 31.55 ± 13.76 years) reported suicidal ideations but denied suicidal attempts or self-harming behavior. Forty-two patients (31 females, mean age 30.64 ± 11.38 years) had episodes of suicidal attempts or self-harming behavior accompanied by suicidal intentions. There were no significant gender or age differences between groups.Participants completed a number of measures of different aspects of meaning and meaninglessness, well-being, ill-being and psychological resources. For some patients ( = 74), a clinical checklist was completed by their doctors assessing 28 various characteristics associated with the patient's clinical status.
Meaningfulness and reasons for living were more helpful in distinguishing between reactions to profound crisis situations (suicidal intentions versus non-suicidal behavior) than were measures of well-being, ill-being, meaning crisis or personality resources. In both suicidal and non-suicidal crisis patients meaningfulness predicted more positive reasons for living. The relationship between meaningfulness and most reasons for living remained significant after controlling for clinically appraised suicidal "readiness," acute stress and lack of social support. Self-transcendence was the major specific source of meaning predicting higher reasons for living after adjusting for general meaningfulness.
The data cast some light on the psychological meaning of suicide. It follows that prevention efforts are to be focused not on eliminating the factors "pushing" one to suicidal behavior, but rather on supporting inner strengths conducive of a positive decision, , through enhancing meaningfulness and reasons for living.
意义是一种重要的心理资源,无论是在成就情境中,还是在持续的逆境和心理危机情境中。生活意义是日常和危急情况下活下去的理由的基础,对生活逆境起到缓冲作用。
本研究的目的是揭示意义(包括意义的具体来源和生活理由)和无意义(疏离感)在患有严重危机情况且有或无自杀意图及行为的患者中的作用。
样本包括148名患者(均为白种人),他们被转介到俄罗斯莫斯科的一个危机中心。77名患者(54名女性,平均年龄32.00±11.98岁)报告称目前生活中存在危机情况,但否认有自杀想法或行为。29名患者(21名女性,平均年龄31.55±13.76岁)报告有自杀意念,但否认有自杀企图或自我伤害行为。42名患者(31名女性,平均年龄30.64±11.38岁)有自杀企图或自我伤害行为发作,并伴有自杀意图。各组之间在性别或年龄上无显著差异。参与者完成了一系列关于意义和无意义、幸福感、痛苦感及心理资源等不同方面的测量。对于部分患者(n =,74),其医生完成了一份临床检查表,评估与患者临床状况相关的28种不同特征。
与幸福感、痛苦感、意义危机或人格资源的测量相比,意义和生活理由在区分对严重危机情况的反应(自杀意图与非自杀行为)方面更有帮助。在有自杀倾向和无自杀倾向的危机患者中,意义都预示着更积极的生活理由。在控制了临床评估的自杀“准备度”、急性应激和缺乏社会支持后,意义与大多数生活理由之间的关系仍然显著。在调整了总体意义后,自我超越是预测更高生活理由的主要特定意义来源。
这些数据揭示了自杀的心理意义。由此可见,预防工作不应侧重于消除促使人们产生自杀行为的因素,而应通过增强意义和生活理由来支持有助于做出积极决定的内在力量。