Peña-Chávez Rodolfo E, Schaen-Heacock Nicole E, Hitchcock Mary E, Kurosu Atsuko, Suzuki Ryo, Hartel Richard W, Ciucci Michelle R, Rogus-Pulia Nicole M
Swallowing and Salivary Bioscience Laboratory, William S. Middleton Memorial Veterans Hospital, Madison, WI, USA.
Department of Communication Sciences & Disorders, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, WI, USA.
Dysphagia. 2023 Jun;38(3):785-817. doi: 10.1007/s00455-022-10525-2. Epub 2022 Oct 20.
Foods and liquids have properties that are often modified as part of clinical dysphagia management to promote safe and efficient swallowing. However, recent studies have questioned whether this practice is supported by the evidence. To address this, a scoping review was conducted to answer the question: "Can properties of food and liquids modify swallowing physiology and function in adults?" Online search in six databases yielded a set of 4235 non-duplicate articles. Using COVIDENCE software, two independent reviewers screened the articles by title and abstract, and 229 full-text articles were selected for full-text review. One-hundred eleven studies met the inclusion criteria for qualitative synthesis and assessment of risk of bias. Three randomized controlled trials and 108 non-randomized studies were analyzed. Large amounts of variability in instrumental assessment, properties of food and liquids, and swallowing measures were found across studies. Sour, sweet, and salty taste, odor, carbonation, capsaicin, viscosity, hardness, adhesiveness, and cohesiveness were reported to modify the oral and pharyngeal phase of swallowing in both healthy participants and patients with dysphagia. Main swallow measures modified by properties of food and liquids were penetration/aspiration, oral transit time, lingual pressures, submental muscle contraction, oral and pharyngeal residue, hyoid and laryngeal movement, pharyngeal and upper esophageal sphincter pressures, and total swallow duration. The evidence pooled in this review supports the clinical practice of food texture and liquid consistency modification in the management of dysphagia with the caveat that all clinical endeavors must be undertaken with a clear rationale and patient-specific evidence that modifying food or liquid benefits swallow safety and efficiency while maintaining quality of life.
食物和液体具有多种特性,在临床吞咽困难管理中,这些特性常常会被改变,以促进安全、高效的吞咽。然而,最近的研究对这种做法是否有证据支持提出了质疑。为解决这一问题,开展了一项范围综述,以回答“食物和液体的特性能否改变成年人的吞咽生理和功能?”这一问题。在六个数据库中进行在线搜索,得到一组4235篇不重复的文章。使用COVIDENCE软件,两名独立评审员通过标题和摘要筛选文章,共选出229篇全文进行全文评审。111项研究符合定性综合和偏倚风险评估的纳入标准。分析了三项随机对照试验和108项非随机研究。研究发现,在仪器评估、食物和液体的特性以及吞咽测量方面存在大量差异。据报道,酸味、甜味、咸味、气味、碳酸化、辣椒素、粘度、硬度、粘附性和内聚性会改变健康参与者和吞咽困难患者吞咽的口腔和咽部阶段。受食物和液体特性影响的主要吞咽测量指标包括渗透/误吸、口腔通过时间、舌压、颏下肌肉收缩、口腔和咽部残留、舌骨和喉部运动、咽部和上食管括约肌压力以及总吞咽持续时间。本综述汇总的证据支持在吞咽困难管理中改变食物质地和液体稠度的临床实践,但需注意的是,所有临床措施都必须有明确的理论依据和针对患者的证据,即改变食物或液体有利于吞咽安全和效率,同时维持生活质量。