Salehomoum Maryam
San Francisco State University, University of California Berkeley, Berkeley, CA, USA.
J Deaf Stud Deaf Educ. 2022 Dec 23;28(1):99-114. doi: 10.1093/deafed/enac037.
This study examined the effect of explicit instruction of reading comprehension strategies, such as identification of unknown vocabulary and relating text to background knowledge, on four deaf and hard of hearing students' use of strategies and reading comprehension performance pre- and post-intervention. Explicit instruction of strategies consisted of discussion of targeted strategies and think-aloud (verbalizing one's thought processes while reading) to model strategies. The data presented is from a more in-depth study completed during the 2017-2018 academic year. Few studies have implemented think-aloud in evaluating deaf adolescents' reading challenges and the efficacy of strategy use. This study provided insight into both of these issues. Results show an increase in the variety of strategies used by students and frequency of strategy use post-intervention. Results also indicate improved comprehension scores for two students. Close examination of the data, however, reveals ongoing metacognitive challenges (such as lack of consistent identification of key unknown words and lack of awareness of comprehension breakdowns) and inconsistency in the efficacious use of strategies. Findings indicate a need for ongoing assessment of the depth and efficacy of strategy use and individualized instruction.
本研究考察了明确教授阅读理解策略(如识别未知词汇以及将文本与背景知识相联系)对四名失聪及听力障碍学生在干预前后策略运用和阅读理解表现的影响。策略的明确教授包括对目标策略的讨论以及出声思考(在阅读时说出自己的思维过程)以示范策略。呈现的数据来自于2017 - 2018学年完成的一项更深入的研究。很少有研究在评估失聪青少年的阅读挑战及策略运用效果时采用出声思考法。本研究为这两个问题提供了见解。结果显示,干预后学生使用的策略种类增加,且策略使用频率提高。结果还表明,两名学生的理解分数有所提高。然而,对数据的仔细审查揭示了持续存在的元认知挑战(如缺乏对关键未知单词的一致识别以及对理解障碍缺乏意识)以及策略有效运用的不一致性。研究结果表明需要持续评估策略运用的深度和效果以及进行个性化教学。