Leszczynski Dariusz
University of Helsinki, Helsinki, Finland.
'Radiation and Health', Frontiers in Public Health, Lausanne, Switzerland.
Rev Environ Health. 2022 Oct 26;39(2):163-189. doi: 10.1515/reveh-2022-0108. Print 2024 Jun 25.
Electromagnetic hypersensitivity (EHS), known also as an idiopathic environmental intolerance attributed to electromagnetic fields (IEI-EMF) or a microwave sickness, is not considered by the World Health Organization (WHO) as being caused by the exposures to electromagnetic fields (EMF). EHS is not recognized as a disease anywhere in the world. Some studies have roughly estimated that 1-10% of the population might experience some form of EHS. However, because of the lack of diagnostic criteria for EHS, these estimates might be either under- or over-estimates. Because the vast majority of human population is exposed to EMF, the possibility of developing EHS from the EMF is a substantial public health issue that should be dealt with globally, even if the individual risk of developing EHS might be small. The WHO recognizes that the symptoms experienced by the EHS persons might be severe and might significantly hamper everyday life. However, after a broad analysis of international and national documents, there seems to be currently no effort to develop health policies for the dealing with EHS, no matter what causes it. National governments, follow the opinions of the WHO and the EMF safety standards setting organizations, the International Commission on Non-Ionizing Radiation Protection (ICNIRP) and the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers - International Committee on Electromagnetic Safety (IEEE-ICES), are not developing any practical health policy advisories for self-declared EHS sufferers. However, symptoms experienced by the self-declared EHS persons affect their well-being and, according to the Constitution of the WHO, are a health problem. Hence, independently of what causes EHS symptoms, this admitted well-being-impairment should be dealt with globally by developing an uniform health policy. Furthermore, WHO, ICNIRP and IEEE-ICES should be advocating and supporting research that would generate a reliable scientific evidence on what are the possible cause(s) of EHS. Without such research there is not possible to develop diagnostic methods as well as any possible mitigation approaches. There is an urgent need for the WHO to advocate for the national governments to urgently develop a comprehensive and common EHS health policy.
电磁超敏反应(EHS),也被称为归因于电磁场的特发性环境不耐受(IEI-EMF)或微波病,世界卫生组织(WHO)并不认为它是由接触电磁场(EMF)引起的。EHS在世界任何地方都不被认可为一种疾病。一些研究粗略估计,1%至10%的人口可能会经历某种形式的EHS。然而,由于缺乏EHS的诊断标准,这些估计可能偏高或偏低。由于绝大多数人都接触EMF,即使个体患EHS的风险可能很小,但因EMF而患上EHS的可能性仍是一个重大的公共卫生问题,应在全球范围内加以应对。WHO认识到EHS患者所经历的症状可能很严重,可能会严重妨碍日常生活。然而,在对国际和国家文件进行广泛分析后,目前似乎没有为应对EHS制定卫生政策的努力,无论其病因是什么。各国政府遵循WHO以及电磁场安全标准制定组织——国际非电离辐射防护委员会(ICNIRP)和电气与电子工程师协会——电磁安全国际委员会(IEEE-ICES)的意见,没有为自称患有EHS的患者制定任何实际的卫生政策建议。然而,自称患有EHS的人所经历的症状会影响他们的幸福感,根据WHO的章程,这是一个健康问题。因此,无论EHS症状的病因是什么,这种公认的幸福感损害都应通过制定统一的卫生政策在全球范围内加以应对。此外,WHO、ICNIRP和IEEE-ICES应倡导并支持相关研究,以产生关于EHS可能病因的可靠科学证据。没有这样的研究,就无法开发诊断方法以及任何可能的缓解方法。迫切需要WHO倡导各国政府紧急制定一项全面且通用的EHS卫生政策。