Habte-Gabr E, Muhe L, Olcen P
Trop Geogr Med. 1987 Apr;39(2):137-43.
Three rapid diagnostic methods for the detection of bacterial antigen-COA (Coagglutination), LA (latex agglutination) and IEOP (immunoelectroosmophoresis); DM (direct microscopy after Gram staining) and culture of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) have been compared in 53 bacterial meningitis patients and in 13 controls. Urine samples were assayed for antigens in connection with CSF in 32 for COA, LA, and IEOP. The cause of meningitis was S. pneumoniae in 31, H. influenzae type b in 16 and N. meningitidis in 6 using the methods for diagnosis by LA in 100%, COA in 94%, culture in 89%, IEOP in 81% and DM in 78% of the CSF samples. None of the CSF from controls were positive by any of the methods. LA and COA detected antigen in CSF in all 4 patients on 4th and 5th day of treatment but none of the tests were helpful 7-10 days later. LA was effective in detecting antigen in urine in 10/10 (100%) H. influenzae type b, 17/20 (85%) S. pneumoniae prior to antibiotic treatment. IEOP was helpful in antigen detection better in serum than in urine in 5/6 H. influenzae type b and 9/11 S. pneumoniae meningitis. In general we have found LA and COA as simple, rapid specific and sensitive tests and can be applied even in field situations and that LA can be used for antigen detection in urine and IEOP in serum. A large scale study is needed in order to standardize methods for antigen detection in serum and urine.
已对用于检测细菌抗原的三种快速诊断方法——协同凝集试验(COA)、乳胶凝集试验(LA)和免疫电渗电泳(IEOP);革兰氏染色后直接显微镜检查(DM)以及脑脊液(CSF)培养,在53例细菌性脑膜炎患者和13例对照中进行了比较。对32例患者的尿液样本进行了与脑脊液相关的抗原检测,采用COA、LA和IEOP方法。使用LA诊断方法,脑膜炎病因在31例中为肺炎链球菌,16例中为b型流感嗜血杆菌,6例中为脑膜炎奈瑟菌,CSF样本中LA诊断率为100%,COA为94%,培养为89%,IEOP为81%,DM为78%。对照的脑脊液样本通过任何方法检测均为阴性。LA和COA在治疗第4天和第5天检测到所有4例患者脑脊液中的抗原,但7 - 10天后所有检测均无帮助。LA在抗生素治疗前能有效检测10/10(100%)b型流感嗜血杆菌、17/20(85%)肺炎链球菌尿液中的抗原。在5/6例b型流感嗜血杆菌和9/11例肺炎链球菌脑膜炎中,IEOP在血清中检测抗原比在尿液中更有帮助。总体而言,我们发现LA和COA是简单、快速、特异且灵敏的检测方法,甚至可应用于现场情况,并且LA可用于尿液中抗原检测,IEOP可用于血清中抗原检测。为了标准化血清和尿液中抗原检测方法,需要进行大规模研究。