Jamal S M, Mitra-Duncan L, Kelly D T, Ben Freedman S
Am J Cardiol. 1987 Sep 1;60(7):525-7. doi: 10.1016/0002-9149(87)90298-0.
A new real-time electrocardiographic (ECG) monitor (QMED Monitor OneTM) was evaluated to assess its accuracy in detecting ischemic ST-segment changes in 43 patients (34 men, 9 women, mean age 56 +/- 11 years) during exercise stress testing. The output of QMED was compared with ST-segment measurements from a Marquette CASE-II computer (ECGM) using a bipolar lead CM5, defining a positive ECG as at least 1 mm of planar or downsloping ST depression. Results were concordant in 33 patients, 15 with both positive and 18 both negative responses, yielding an accuracy (expressed as sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative predictive accuracy) of 83%, 72%, 68% and 86%, respectively. Seven false-positive QMED episodes occurred: 4 due to excess baseline wander or noise in the control ECG, which may have been prevented by reapplication of electrodes, and all 7 episodes were correctly discounted by inspection of the sample ischemic ECG output, yielding an accuracy of 81%, 100%, 100% and 85%. Mean duration and maximal magnitude of ST depression in patients with a positive ECG response was 7.9 +/- 7 minutes and 1.7 +/- 0.6 mm for QMED and 8.9 +/- 7 minutes and 2.2 +/- 0.7 mm for ECGM. The 3 false-negative QMED events were relatively brief and mild ischemic episodes and slight differences in electrode placement between the 2 systems may account for this discrepancy in 2 of the patients. Real-time ST monitoring with QMED is sufficiently reliable for clinical use. Optimal specificity depends on the ability to inspect sample ECG traces to verify a stable baseline and confirm episodes of ischemic ST-segment shift.
对一种新型实时心电图(ECG)监测仪(QMED Monitor OneTM)进行了评估,以测定其在43例患者(34例男性,9例女性,平均年龄56±11岁)运动负荷试验期间检测缺血性ST段改变的准确性。使用双极导联CM5,将QMED的输出结果与Marquette CASE-II计算机(ECGM)的ST段测量结果进行比较,将至少1毫米的平面或下斜型ST段压低定义为心电图阳性。33例患者的结果一致,15例为阳性反应,18例为阴性反应,其准确性(以敏感性、特异性、阳性和阴性预测准确性表示)分别为83%、72%、68%和86%。发生了7次QMED假阳性事件:4次是由于对照心电图中基线漂移过多或存在噪声,重新放置电极可能会避免这种情况,通过检查缺血性心电图输出样本,所有7次事件均被正确排除,准确性分别为81%、100%、100%和85%。心电图阳性反应患者的ST段压低平均持续时间和最大幅度,QMED分别为7.9±7分钟和1.7±0.6毫米,ECGM分别为8.9±7分钟和2.2±0.7毫米。3次QMED假阴性事件为相对短暂和轻度的缺血发作,两个系统之间电极放置的细微差异可能是2例患者出现这种差异的原因。使用QMED进行实时ST段监测在临床上具有足够的可靠性。最佳特异性取决于检查心电图样本轨迹以验证稳定基线并确认缺血性ST段移位发作的能力。