Munuera Jérôme, Burguière Eric
Sorbonne Université, Institut du Cerveau-Paris Brain Institute-ICM, Inserm, CNRS, AP-HP, Hôpital de la Pitié Salpêtrière, Paris, France.
Institut Jean Nicod, Département d'Études Cognitives, École Normale Supérieure (ENS), EHESS, CNRS, PSL University, Paris, France.
Front Behav Neurosci. 2022 Oct 13;16:996955. doi: 10.3389/fnbeh.2022.996955. eCollection 2022.
Climate change is an undeniable fact that will certainly affect millions of people in the following decades. Despite this danger threatening our economies, wellbeing and our lives in general, there is a lack of immediate response at both the institutional and individual level. How can it be that the human brain cannot interpret this threat and act against it to avoid the immense negative consequences that may ensue? Here we argue that this paradox could be explained by the fact that some key brain mechanisms are potentially poorly tuned to take action against a threat that would take full effect only in the long-term. We present neuro-behavioral evidence in favor of this proposal and discuss the role of the dopaminergic (DA) system in learning accurate prediction of the value of an outcome, and its consequences regarding the climate issue. We discuss how this system discounts the value of delayed outcomes and, consequently, does not favor action against the climate crisis. Finally, according to this framework, we suggest that this view may be reconsidered and, on the contrary, that the DA reinforcement learning system could be a powerful ally if adapted to short-term incentives which promote climate-friendly behaviors. Additionally, the DA system interacts with multiple brain systems, in particular those related to higher cognitive functions, which can adjust its functions depending on psychological, social, or other complex contextual information. Thus, we propose several generic action plans that could help to hack these neuro-behavioral processes to promote climate-friendly actions.
气候变化是一个不可否认的事实,在接下来的几十年里肯定会影响数百万人。尽管这种危险威胁着我们的经济、福祉以及总体生活,但在机构和个人层面都缺乏即时响应。人类大脑怎么会无法理解这种威胁并采取行动来避免可能随之而来的巨大负面后果呢?在此,我们认为这个悖论可以通过以下事实来解释:一些关键的大脑机制可能在针对一种仅在长期才会完全显现其影响的威胁采取行动方面调节不佳。我们展示了支持这一观点的神经行为学证据,并讨论了多巴胺能(DA)系统在学习准确预测结果价值方面的作用,以及其在气候问题上的后果。我们讨论了该系统如何降低延迟结果的价值,因此不利于针对气候危机采取行动。最后,根据这一框架,我们建议可以重新审视这一观点,相反,如果多巴胺能强化学习系统适应促进气候友好型行为的短期激励措施,它可能成为一个有力的助力。此外,多巴胺能系统与多个大脑系统相互作用,特别是那些与高级认知功能相关的系统,这些系统可以根据心理、社会或其他复杂的情境信息来调整其功能。因此,我们提出了几个通用的行动计划,可能有助于破解这些神经行为过程以促进气候友好型行动。