Cairns Hospital, James Cook University, Cairns, Queensland, Australia.
James Cook University, Cairns, Queensland, Australia.
Aust N Z J Obstet Gynaecol. 2023 Apr;63(2):247-253. doi: 10.1111/ajo.13617. Epub 2022 Nov 5.
There is currently a gender imbalance 85:15 female/male in the intake into specialist training for the Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (RANZCOG).
To determine the views and perceptions of Australian medical students, and junior doctors in the first five years of practice, toward obstetrics and gynaecology (O&G) as a career, including whether there are any perceived barriers to the pursuit of such a career.
A semi-structured questionnaire was developed with members of the RANZCOG Gender Equity and Diversity Working Group There were two separate studies: the first involved telephone interviews of medical students across three campuses of a medical school in North Queensland. The second study surveyed junior doctors in Queensland who are members of the Australian Medical Association. Responses were analysed and compared using quantitative and qualitative methods.
Both studies found that experiences with O&G as a medical student influenced the decision to pursue O&G as a career. Exclusion from clinical scenarios and difficulty establishing good relationship with midwives within busy birthing suites were some reasons deterring male students from O&G. In addition, students felt poorly informed about the specialty in their preclinical years, affecting their early decisions in choice of specialty. Post-rotation, more female than male students reported positive experiences and were considering O&G as a career.
Both groups see medical student experience as critical in attitudes toward the specialty as a possible career. This experience plays a significant role in encouraging female students toward a career in O&G and discouraging male students. More exposure to the specialty in the preclinical years, and attention to improving clinical rotations for all students, is required.
在澳大利亚和新西兰皇家妇产科医师学院(RANZCOG)的专科培训中,目前存在着 85:15 的男女比例失衡现象。
旨在了解澳大利亚医学生和从业 5 年内的初级医生对妇产科(Obstetrics and Gynaecology,O&G)职业的看法和认知,包括是否存在追求该职业的潜在障碍。
RANZCOG 性别平等与多样性工作组的成员共同制定了一份半结构化问卷。本研究包含两项独立的研究:第一项研究涉及对北昆士兰一所医学院三个校区的医学生进行电话访谈。第二项研究调查了昆士兰州的初级医生,他们均为澳大利亚医学协会的成员。使用定量和定性方法分析和比较了这些研究的结果。
这两项研究均发现,医学生的妇产科经历会影响他们是否选择妇产科作为职业。在忙碌的产房里,学生被排除在临床场景之外,且与助产士建立良好关系的难度较大,这是一些促使男学生对妇产科望而却步的原因。此外,学生在基础临床阶段对该专业了解甚少,这影响了他们在选择专业时的早期决策。轮科结束后,与男性相比,更多的女性报告了积极的经历,并考虑将妇产科作为职业选择。
两组人群均认为医学生的经历对于他们对妇产科职业的态度至关重要。这种经历在鼓励女性学生从事妇产科工作和劝阻男性学生方面发挥了重要作用。需要在基础临床阶段增加对该专业的接触,并关注改善所有学生的临床轮科体验。