Department of Emergency Medicine, Singapore General Hospital, Singapore; Pre-hospital and Emergency Research Centre, Duke-NUS Medical School, Singapore.
School of Clinical Medicine, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK.
Lancet Public Health. 2022 Nov;7(11):e932-e941. doi: 10.1016/S2468-2667(22)00234-1.
Previous studies have reported positive associations between out-of-hospital cardiac arrest (OHCA) and air pollutant concentrations, but there are inconsistencies across studies. We aimed to investigate the association between pollutant concentrations and the risk of OHCA in Singapore.
We did a time series analysis of all cases of OHCA in Singapore reported between July 1, 2010, and Dec 31, 2018, to the Pan-Asian Resuscitation Outcomes Study (PAROS), a prospective, population-based registry. Using multivariable fractional polynomial modelling, we investigated the immediate (day 0) and lagged (up to 5 days after exposure) association between 10 μg/m increases in concentrations of particulate matter with a diameter of 2·5 μm or smaller (PM), particulate matter with a diameter of 10 μm or smaller (PM), ozone (O), nitrogen dioxide (NO), and sulphur dioxide (SO) and 1 mg/m increase in carbon monoxide (CO) and relative risk (RR) of OHCA.
We extracted data for 18 131 cases of OHCA. The median age of this cohort of cases was 65 years (IQR 56-80), 6484 (35·8%) were female, 11 647 (64·2%) were male, 12 270 (67·7%) were Chinese, 2873 (15·8%) were Malay, and 2010 (11·1%) were Indian. Every 10 μg/m increase in PM was associated with increased risk of OHCA (RR 1·022 [95% 1·002-1·043]) over the next 2 days, which decreased over the subsequent 3 days (3-5 days after exposure; 0·976 [0·955-0·998]). For PM, O, NO, and SO, we did not observe any associations between increased concentration and risk of OHCA on day 0 or cumulative risk over time (ie, at 0-1 days, 0-2 days, 0-3 days, 0-4 days, 0-5 days, and 3-5 days after exposure). For CO, we observed a cumulative decreased risk of OHCA across 0-5 days after exposure (0·876 [0·770-0·997]) and at days 3-5 after exposure (0·810 [0·690-0·949]). We observed effect modification of the association between increasing PM concentration and OHCA 0-2 days after exposure by cardiac arrest rhythm (non-shockable 1·027 [1·004-1·050] vs shockable 1·002 [0·956-1·051]) and location of OHCA (at home: 1·033 [1·008-1·057] vs not at home 0·955 [0·957-1·035]). In hypothetical modelling, the number of OHCA events associated with PM could be reduced by 8% with a 1 μg/m decrease in PM concentrations and by 30% with a 3 μg/m decrease in PM concentrations.
Increases in PM concentration were associated with an initial increased risk of OHCA and a subsequent reduced risk from 3-5 days after exposure, suggesting a short-term harvesting effect. A decrease in PM concentrations could reduce population demand for emergency health services.
National Medical Research Council, Singapore, under the Clinician Scientist Award, Singapore and the Singapore Translational Research Investigator Award (MOH-000982-01).
先前的研究报告指出,院外心脏骤停(OHCA)与空气污染物浓度之间存在正相关关系,但研究结果存在不一致。我们旨在调查新加坡污染物浓度与 OHCA 风险之间的关系。
我们对 2010 年 7 月 1 日至 2018 年 12 月 31 日期间向泛亚洲复苏结果研究(PAROS)报告的新加坡所有 OHCA 病例进行了时间序列分析,这是一项前瞻性、基于人群的登记研究。我们使用多变量分数多项式模型,调查了暴露后 10 μg/m³增加的粒径为 2.5 μm 或以下的颗粒物(PM)、粒径为 10 μm 或以下的颗粒物(PM)、臭氧(O)、二氧化氮(NO)和二氧化硫(SO)浓度以及一氧化碳(CO)浓度每增加 1 mg/m³与 OHCA 风险的即时(第 0 天)和滞后(暴露后 5 天内)关联。
我们提取了 18131 例 OHCA 病例的数据。该病例队列的中位年龄为 65 岁(IQR 56-80),6484 例(35.8%)为女性,11647 例(64.2%)为男性,12270 例(67.7%)为华人,2873 例(15.8%)为马来人,2010 例(11.1%)为印度人。PM 每增加 10 μg/m³,接下来的 2 天内 OHCA 的风险增加(RR 1.022 [95% 1.002-1.043]),随后 3 天内(暴露后 3-5 天)风险降低(0.976 [0.955-0.998])。对于 PM、O、NO 和 SO,我们没有观察到暴露当天或随着时间推移(即 0-1 天、0-2 天、0-3 天、0-4 天、0-5 天和 3-5 天)的浓度增加与 OHCA 风险之间的任何关联。对于 CO,我们观察到暴露后 0-5 天的 OHCA 风险逐渐降低(0.876 [0.770-0.997])和暴露后 3-5 天的风险降低(0.810 [0.690-0.949])。我们观察到暴露后 0-2 天 PM 浓度增加与 OHCA 之间的关联存在效应修饰,取决于心脏骤停节律(非冲击性 1.027 [1.004-1.050] 与冲击性 1.002 [0.956-1.051])和 OHCA 发生地点(在家中 1.033 [1.008-1.057] 与不在家中 0.955 [0.957-1.035])。在假设模型中,PM 相关的 OHCA 事件数量可能会减少 8%,PM 浓度降低 1μg/m³,减少 30%,PM 浓度降低 3μg/m³。
PM 浓度的增加与 OHCA 的初始风险增加有关,随后在暴露后 3-5 天内风险降低,表明存在短期收获效应。PM 浓度的降低可能会降低对紧急医疗服务的人群需求。
新加坡国家医学研究理事会,在临床科学家奖、新加坡和新加坡转化研究研究员奖(MOH-000982-01)下资助。