Wood D R, Blome R M, Ribeiro L C, Keunen A J, Keunen B W, Crenshaw J D, Campbell J M, Renaud D L
Animix, Juneau, WI 53039.
Mapleview Agri, Palmerston, ON, Canada N0G 2P0.
JDS Commun. 2021 Oct 9;2(6):340-344. doi: 10.3168/jdsc.2021-0112. eCollection 2021 Nov.
The objective of this trial was to compare the health and performance of calves provided high feeding rates of a whey-based all-milk-protein calf milk replacer (MR) with those fed an MR containing either 5% or 10% porcine plasma, which replaced, respectively, either 15% or 30% of the whey-based proteins in the MR formula. A total of 320 male Holstein calves weighing a mean (± SD) of 47.8 ± 4.1 kg were sourced from local dairy farms, auction facilities, and local order buyers. Calves arrived at the research facility in 4 batches of 80 animals each and were randomly assigned to 1 of 3 groups: (1) MR composed of whey-based milk proteins (control group); (2) whey replacement of 5% spray-dried porcine plasma (replacing 15% of protein); or (3) whey replacement of 10% spray-dried porcine plasma (replacing 30% of protein). Calves were housed in individual pens for the first 56 d of the experiment and offered, twice daily, a 26% crude protein (CP), 20% fat MR standardized using synthetic amino acids to 2.4% lysine, 0.8% methionine, and 1.6% threonine. Amounts of MR offered from wk 1 to 8 were 0.65, 0.78, 0.91, 1.04, 1.04, 0.78, 0.52, and 0.325 kg/d, respectively. Calves were also offered a 20% CP texturized calf starter from d 0 to 56 and then transitioned over 7 d (d 56-62) of a 50% calf starter and 50% corn and pellet ration with 2% straw to a corn and pellet ration with 2% straw (18.1% CP) for the remainder of the experiment (d 63-77). Calves were individually weighed upon arrival, weekly through d 56, and at d 77. Grain was fed ad libitum, and remaining grain was weighed weekly to determine weekly consumption. Remaining grain was discarded and was replaced with fresh grain that was weighed and recorded. All milk was offered individually via bucket twice daily, and refusals were recorded following milk feeding by weighing back the remaining unconsumed milk solution. Calves were health scored twice daily, and any medical treatments or mortality were recorded. Time to mortality and medical treatments were analyzed using survival analysis, health scoring data were analyzed using a generalized linear model, and growth was evaluated using a mixed repeated-measures linear regression model. No differences in mortality or incidence of diarrhea were noted between groups. Although there was a high incidence of respiratory disease (65%), no differences were found between groups. Over the entire experimental period, calves gained 67.0 ± 14.9 kg; however, no differences in growth among groups were noted, with the exception that, on d 77, BW was greater for calves in the control group (115.8 ± 15.5 kg) compared with those fed a MR with 5% porcine plasma (113.4 ± 17.8 kg). No differences were found between groups with respect to feed conversion. In this study, an MR composed of either 5% or 10% spray-dried porcine plasma performed comparably to a whey protein-based MR.
本试验的目的是比较以乳清为基础的全乳蛋白犊牛代乳粉(MR)高饲喂量的犊牛与饲喂含5%或10%猪血浆的MR的犊牛的健康状况和生产性能,其中5%或10%的猪血浆分别替代了MR配方中15%或30%的乳清蛋白。总共320头平均体重(±标准差)为47.8±4.1千克的雄性荷斯坦犊牛来自当地奶牛场、拍卖场和当地订单买家。犊牛分4批抵达研究设施,每批80头,并随机分配到3组中的1组:(1)由乳清基乳蛋白组成的MR(对照组);(2)用5%喷雾干燥猪血浆替代乳清(替代15%的蛋白质);或(3)用10%喷雾干燥猪血浆替代乳清(替代30%的蛋白质)。在试验的前56天,犊牛单独饲养在个体栏中,每天两次提供一种粗蛋白(CP)含量为26%、脂肪含量为20%的MR,该MR使用合成氨基酸标准化为赖氨酸含量2.4%、蛋氨酸含量0.8%、苏氨酸含量1.6%。第1至8周提供的MR量分别为0.65、0.78、0.91、1.04、1.04、0.78、0.52和0.325千克/天。从第0天到第56天,还给犊牛提供了一种CP含量为20%的颗粒状犊牛开食料,然后在7天内(第56 - 62天)过渡到50%犊牛开食料和50%玉米与颗粒料(含2%秸秆)的日粮,在试验剩余时间(第63 - 77天)过渡到含2%秸秆的玉米与颗粒料日粮(CP含量18.1%)。犊牛抵达时、至第56天每周以及第77天进行个体称重。谷物自由采食,每周称量剩余谷物以确定每周采食量。剩余谷物丢弃,并用新鲜称量并记录的谷物替代。所有牛奶每天分两次通过桶单独提供,喂奶后通过称量剩余未消耗的牛奶溶液记录剩余量。每天对犊牛进行两次健康评分,并记录任何医疗处理或死亡情况。使用生存分析分析死亡时间和医疗处理情况,使用广义线性模型分析健康评分数据,使用混合重复测量线性回归模型评估生长情况。各实验组之间在死亡率或腹泻发病率方面未发现差异。尽管呼吸道疾病发病率较高(65%),但各实验组之间未发现差异。在整个试验期内,犊牛增重67.0±14.9千克;然而,各实验组之间在生长方面未发现差异,不过在第77天,对照组犊牛的体重(115.8±15.5千克)高于饲喂含5%猪血浆MR的犊牛(113.4±17.8千克)。各实验组在饲料转化率方面未发现差异。在本研究中,含5%或10%喷雾干燥猪血浆的MR与基于乳清蛋白的MR表现相当。