Herbert Robyn S, Evans Spencer C, Guler Jessy, Roberts Michael C
Department of Psychology, Washington State University, Pullman, WA.
Department of Psychology, University of Miami, Coral Gables, FL.
Train Educ Prof Psychol. 2022 Nov;16(4):394-402. doi: 10.1037/tep0000371. Epub 2021 May 6.
A doctoral dissertation constitutes a student's original research and a novel contribution to scientific knowledge. Yet, few psychology dissertations, particularly in professional subfields, are published in the peer-reviewed literature, and the reasons for this are unclear. The present study investigated student, advisor, and doctoral program variables that might predict dissertation publication in professional psychology. Using a stratified random cohort sample of 169 Ph.D. dissertations in clinical and counseling psychology, we conducted exhaustive searches to determine whether dissertation studies were published in peer-reviewed journals within 0-7 years following their completion. Logistic regression models were estimated to test whether dissertation publication was predicted by student and advisor prior research productivity, dissertation length, and doctoral program's training emphasis, accreditation status, and subfield. Results indicated that dissertations that were supervised by more research-productive advisors and that were relatively brief (<180 pages) were significantly more likely to be published in peer-reviewed journals. No other predictors were significant. Results are discussed with regard to implications for training and mentorship. Faculty advisors who publish frequently might be more likely to attract research-oriented students, to mentor students in preparing a publishable dissertation, and/or to encourage students to publish their dissertation research. By systematically promoting research dissemination as part of doctoral research training, graduate programs and faculty mentors in clinical and counseling psychology could help facilitate students' sharing their dissertation findings with the scientific community.
博士学位论文是学生的原创研究,是对科学知识的新颖贡献。然而,很少有心理学博士论文,尤其是专业子领域的论文,在同行评审文献中发表,其原因尚不清楚。本研究调查了可能预测专业心理学领域博士论文发表情况的学生、导师和博士项目变量。我们使用了169篇临床与咨询心理学博士论文的分层随机队列样本,进行了详尽的检索,以确定论文研究在完成后的0至7年内是否发表于同行评审期刊。估计了逻辑回归模型,以检验论文发表是否可由学生和导师先前的研究产出、论文长度以及博士项目的培训重点、认证状态和子领域来预测。结果表明,由研究产出更高的导师指导且篇幅相对较短(<180页)的论文,在同行评审期刊上发表的可能性显著更高。没有其他预测因素具有显著性。讨论了这些结果对培训和指导的启示。经常发表论文的教师顾问可能更有可能吸引以研究为导向的学生,指导学生撰写可发表的博士论文,和/或鼓励学生发表他们的论文研究。通过将研究成果传播作为博士研究培训的一部分进行系统推广,临床与咨询心理学的研究生项目和教师导师可以帮助促进学生与科学界分享他们的论文研究成果。