Chapa J M, Lidauer L, Steininger A, Öhlschuster M, Potrusil T, Sigler M, Auer W, Azizzadeh M, Drillich M, Iwersen M
FFoQSI GmbH-Austrian Competence Centre for Feed and Food Quality, Safety and Innovation, Technopark 1C, 3430 Tulln, Austria.
Clinical Unit for Herd Health Management in Ruminants, University Clinic for Ruminants, Department for Farm Animals and Veterinary Public Health, University of Veterinary Medicine Vienna, 1210 Vienna, Austria.
JDS Commun. 2021 Jun 23;2(4):217-222. doi: 10.3168/jdsc.2020-0050. eCollection 2021 Jul.
Automated sensor-based monitoring of cows has become an important tool in herd management to improve or maintain animal health and welfare. Location systems offer the ability to locate animals within the barn for, for example, artificial insemination. Furthermore, they have the potential to measure the time cows spend in important areas of the barn, which might indicate need for improvement in the management of the herd or individuals. In this study, we tested the sensor-based real-time location system (RTLS) Smartbow (SB, Smartbow GmbH) under field conditions. The objectives of this study were (1) to determine the accuracy of the system to predict the location of the cow and the agreement between visual observations and RTLS observations for the total time spent by cows in relevant areas of the barn and (2) to compare the performance of 2 different algorithms (Alg1 and Alg2) for cow location. The study was conducted on a commercial Austrian dairy farm. In total, 35 lactating cows were video recorded for 3 consecutive days. From these recordings, approximately 1 h was selected randomly each day for every cow (3 d × 35 cows). Simultaneously, location data were collected and classified by the RTLS system as dedicated to the alley, feed bunk, or cubicle on a 1-min resolution. A total of 6,030 paired observations were derived from visual observations (VO) and the RTLS and used for the final data analysis. Substantial agreement of categorical data between VO and SB was obtained by Cohen's kappa for both algorithms (Alg1 = 0.76 and Alg2 = 0.78). Similar results were achieved by both algorithms throughout the study, with a slight improvement for Alg2. The ability of the system to locate the cows in the predefined areas was assessed, and the results from Alg2 showed sensitivity, specificity, and positive predictive value of alley (74.0, 91.2, and 76.9%), feed bunk (93.5, 86.2, and 89.1%), and cubicle (90.5, 83.3, and 95.4%) and an overall accuracy of 87.6%.The correlation coefficient (r) between VO and SB for the total time cows spent (within 1 h) in the predefined areas was good to strong (r = 0.82, 0.98, and 0.92 for alley, feed bunk, and cubicle, respectively). These results show the potential of the system to automatically assess total time spent by cows in important areas of the barn for indoor settings. Future studies should focus on evaluating 24-h periods to assess time budgets and to combine technologies such as accelerometers and location systems to improve the performance of behavior prediction in dairy cows.
基于自动传感器的奶牛监测已成为畜群管理中的一项重要工具,用于改善或维持动物健康和福利。定位系统能够在畜舍内定位动物,例如用于人工授精。此外,它们有潜力测量奶牛在畜舍重要区域所花费的时间,这可能表明畜群或个体的管理需要改进。在本研究中,我们在实地条件下测试了基于传感器的实时定位系统(RTLS)Smartbow(SB,Smartbow GmbH公司)。本研究的目的是:(1)确定该系统预测奶牛位置的准确性,以及奶牛在畜舍相关区域所花费的总时间的视觉观察与RTLS观察之间的一致性;(2)比较两种不同算法(Alg1和Alg2)用于奶牛定位的性能。该研究在奥地利一家商业奶牛场进行。总共对35头泌乳奶牛连续3天进行了视频记录。从这些记录中,每天为每头奶牛随机选择约1小时(3天×35头奶牛)。同时,RTLS系统收集位置数据并以1分钟的分辨率将其分类为专用通道、饲料槽或牛栏。总共从视觉观察(VO)和RTLS获得了6030对配对观察数据,并用于最终数据分析。对于两种算法(Alg1 = 0.76,Alg2 = 0.78),VO和SB之间的分类数据通过Cohen's kappa获得了实质性一致性。在整个研究中,两种算法都取得了类似的结果,Alg2略有改进。评估了该系统在预定义区域定位奶牛的能力,Alg2的结果显示通道的敏感性、特异性和阳性预测值分别为(74.0%、91.2%和76.9%),饲料槽为(93.5%、86.2%和89.1%),牛栏为(90.5%、83.3%和95.4%),总体准确率为87.6%。奶牛在预定义区域(1小时内)所花费的总时间的VO和SB之间的相关系数(r)良好至很强(通道、饲料槽和牛栏的r分别为0.82、0.98和0.92)。这些结果表明该系统有潜力自动评估奶牛在室内畜舍重要区域所花费的总时间。未来的研究应侧重于评估24小时时间段以评估时间预算,并结合加速度计和定位系统等技术,以提高奶牛行为预测的性能。