Péter Hella, Laporte Marion, Newton-Fisher Nicholas E, Reynolds Vernon, Samuni Liran, Soldati Adrian, Vigilant Linda, Villioth Jakob, Graham Kirsty E, Zuberbühler Klaus, Hobaiter Catherine
School of Anthropology and Conservation.
Unite Mixte de Recherche.
J Comp Psychol. 2022 Nov;136(4):255-269. doi: 10.1037/com0000327. Epub 2022 Nov 7.
Associating with kin provides individual benefits but requires that these relationships be detectable. In humans, facial phenotype matching might help assess paternity; however, evidence for it is mixed. In chimpanzees, concealing visual cues of paternity may be beneficial due to their promiscuous mating system and the considerable risk of infanticide by males. On the other hand, detecting kin can also aid chimpanzees in avoiding inbreeding and in forming alliances that improve kin-mediated fitness. Although previous studies assessing relatedness based on facial resemblance in chimpanzees exist, they used images of captive populations in whom selection pressures and reproductive opportunities are controlled and only assessed maternity or paternity of adult offspring. In natural populations, the chances of infanticide are highest during early infancy, suggesting that young infants would benefit most from paternity concealment, whereas adults and subadults would benefit from the detection of all types of kin, including half-siblings. In our experiment, we conducted an online study with human participants, in which they had to assess the relatedness of chimpanzees based on facial similarity. To address previous methodological constraints, we used chimpanzee images across all ages, as well as maternal and paternal half-siblings. We found that kin status was detected above chance across all relatedness categories, with easier kin detection of father-offspring pairs, females, and older chimpanzees. Together, these findings support the existence of paternity confusion in infant chimpanzees and provide a possible mechanism for incest avoidance and kin-based social alliances in older individuals. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2022 APA, all rights reserved).
与亲属交往能给个体带来好处,但前提是这些关系能够被识别。在人类中,面部表型匹配可能有助于评估亲子关系;然而,相关证据并不一致。在黑猩猩中,由于它们混乱的交配系统以及雄性杀婴的巨大风险,隐藏亲子关系的视觉线索可能是有益的。另一方面,识别亲属也有助于黑猩猩避免近亲繁殖,并形成能提高亲属介导适应性的联盟。尽管之前有研究基于黑猩猩的面部相似性评估亲属关系,但这些研究使用的是圈养种群的图像,在圈养种群中,选择压力和繁殖机会受到控制,而且只评估成年后代的母系或父系亲子关系。在自然种群中,杀婴的几率在婴儿早期最高,这表明年幼的婴儿从隐藏父系关系中获益最大,而成年和亚成年个体则从识别所有类型的亲属(包括同父异母或同母异父的兄弟姐妹)中获益。在我们的实验中,我们对人类参与者进行了一项在线研究,让他们根据面部相似度评估黑猩猩之间的亲属关系。为了解决之前方法上的限制,我们使用了所有年龄段的黑猩猩图像,以及同父异母和同母异父的兄弟姐妹。我们发现,在所有亲属关系类别中,亲属身份的识别率都高于随机水平,其中父子对、雌性黑猩猩和年龄较大的黑猩猩的亲属关系更容易被识别。这些发现共同支持了幼年黑猩猩中存在父系关系混淆的观点,并为年长个体避免乱伦和基于亲属关系的社会联盟提供了一种可能的机制。(PsycInfo数据库记录(c)2022美国心理学会,保留所有权利)